Balaghat Al Iqna3

Lali uligiltio / LALANE I jgiitio cables ELAkitilet 5 DIFAFPU SUCHIN eer prat Gyisliol! noAGUS Fege obthsl dil Lys alb TSU! yl ceall GILLI La aay I 8 Y Lguhy Lisa Lee Lato Bl os Lao, lalatal 3S} Ladin 2a gbl eel" UL Gy, Gell Sal pays" Lede seis Leones Kuelve Legblyyo| Of LeLust Si G2 5Ui Jaa aval juolaall All cain GIST GUE, Syyuall bo ai Glut le gas pbcllaly cslatey Nie Sa 2 VI oSS2 I Say ata pels ZI Lal Ue poles JS lla saul (8 By pinnel as AM os82y daz es Le AS aly "Leasly Lele casa ol lt Gbeldy Gadlll poll Le534 GLAS cyabll slay! Jai oslo! Gill JM "Eatin Jy Vl Leiba ys ie AE SLI ISM Blsy! thal La" [puts Sues ail ae dL! SSS Ralall phe Ugg NURS Ups! Ja Y ila] Ueesbeatel yy Le es LEN Lyell SLM 9 dais Le Gay ELL, lies 2bLidl lbs Alas Go 22! oly qecleell sual! lel yh p Lay! dL, GUS pLaal 5 Lygene” Gases Sl LG! yng Lao See Sie RESLM puy cell Shiga Jaolly Galil! ao YS cabls." YL Tale Uslaally sLaall ob Qo acpi play yale SEES poles! EUs ns Si ola, GLY! BULAN GUS (8 Gull pou} LI cp dys de lgall desde Ga LELODEIIjguiliso DIFAFPUBLISHING editions.difaf@gmatl.com elisa eu, Spbliall ns ale sabi) sici.s otal 5 lS Collis ilgitio a Saat Su ‘editions etikief@gmai.comAybligl 4 cli Ae LsAlig, lial Az lb ale cial) uc . 2 sNiUgtio fro LSLEACIIjquitio Editon Eats ULOU} DIFAFP vats HING buyAs) dal e 2013 - 2 1434 978-614-01-0506-5 Aas) 4B gas gyal! Quen LaLanljguilio DIFARPUBLISHING editions.difaf@gmail.com Ob) — S522 allzslilcahgit Edit aati ger otes CE 149 Pipl — doll sat +213 21 676179 :_-SU / le e-mail: editions.elikhtilef@gmail.com Jal isNjy le bu JI Ei pall 54 Ap (212) 537.20.00.55 :_-SWl ~ (212) 537.72.32.76 alg! UJ 0 darelamane@menara.ma ‘44 ,SVi4,J) Us $i Ag 3511 of Aayagict My daly GLSII Nae Gee aja gl Jleaiul gh Gud gies Asi ghdeg pte ol ySi gh Alo pth phe Jumrutlly 2 yd 9h gi! emul dad Ley Slee npAUSI Gy lad Dal dogs (y Lgole paurly slaglat! dado Lgud Les gsi GUA oly Ge Aya nual pus Y USS fia 8 Baylghl AMO!Js) gta gay AB) Jay BHI Lu psi cpt ll Slaall pliiy Ab D4: 99) Jaa - Sg Alaa g (lad gull 2g) Cony AGS EWN SL Wel) LAGS -1 atlend pU eleol gy pall -2 gel ake LEN ASS haat) plata Conga plas cleo gle bo) flag Olde 3-1 Cradlland pS EIST Gt aw sh ole ye Byles -2 Chr ali oLa>VI I earl Byybu -3 cg tesll Casita sil" Gaull gu jf CN doxsall wn ge bred) slau sl gy pte Jo dela] -1 Jat St Pane «(Les Topiques eA! yall) "Ley sll" Obs -2 vn gladll Claes} lass! -3 son SDI Claes gh Ld SI lS -4 gh Dhan op 98) Cl fl gd pLBY) ABD + tt Jul Sia gill bag yg Hind 258) yall Tinted tie cleeall Ue iL} -1 - Libel 4294 (3 pl SY! -2dinlell Bb of pLBY! dab -3 AGES gp Wz 395 plist] OLA)] 4 Ht) by 9 Abs de Slams) icpilill Conall 68 ae ety cglee Gla Je sels] -I hy Gl be OLS -2 oot ey gil Oleg) geLSY! dal -3 cron) ABS 9 sisal ON cay songSEoS ce Clr Uy Gel] =] SES BH 3 VY -2 CUB J plist! p39 -3 Stall by pal BY daedall 4 ipsa gp il Saale plyl Abd 22 ual 83. gldyl dbdy Glaly Old yy sd g¥) Cyall 83... OLS ped ge bool gy pall Um dels] 1 87 gles lille -2 gee sail g 9899 ARM b gla gt] Call EAN clredl Ey yee dye La] -1 leet 3999 Pragmatique intégrée Smeal} LJ lil -2 ilrodl BAI -3 derlrodll EAL yell 4 gzbredl olzs i -5 Marqueurs argumentatifs iteoul 1 al -6 wwLa classe argumentative (z-lrod! ill -7 La force argumentative 4,>-leoJ! 3531 -8 wweeechelle argumentative Lge oo -9 610: 103 103 Aplaun dls gtpall gf syle Jldye sell! coal ple lt ¢y ta Ue be] -1 le tae) ciel gy pall -2 als Slee £5 phe gh Stay SAU -3 phe Slt G3 phe cyand lool 4 Jhgall Aap laas y shh ya dla gy il Canal 109... son Pele] 3 yo Ble gy phe Je bela] =1 so Ngeul 3 Walia! -2 U2 soo Seal gi Uthat 3 washout sel gs -4 ayshoeall B cledl -5 Ae ll key 3 cleedl 1.5 M5 ce wn ddshall Bey J cles -2.5 soon BBW J guard Ub pt (gine yp 12 gli — 120... som SS gall asl gil ll (hel gill Gal J | bLial) wet ea a pall Cl sl ob 5 pa Gaailad ig gl all BBL Gis pi 68 9) Call Aged Ay yall ABU ob 5 BL A 3S yo Uhl Coal 7sone Saf Hay all 8 BU Ci jane of 28 Conga naga) agp ll Cl AG Ua ke gage hs yl I Conga snngge aN agp ol) Ga A 5 Jlball ddan ual) Call Baia y gad g 6 gil dal ge 2 iltll Jucill Mkt) yaeall y 5 paLiall 0) gi) Gaga)
Lia od glill 2G Jacl sb PBNGal) oA (aba AT tl 2 I Canyall Tabled 3 Jol fads al 1 Lead oS aryl fads el -2pill SAN, plas Vy cls Call 5 BLL (gb saat raul tl Jualll Anat Aza lgall Ayan iJ git) Conall son ggll ll AAU cgi Conga cg.) sala] 2a} Cony AMEN GN Lal, 235 on . iS cg gp all EN all 6b 5 BU Gaal added Ga = gal ally atadll 10. MS) Syollall Sue 74) oll! senggaly gil ot shay Ahly tly Anyod) Aad Gl! itedly isd! otdonne (pt Mae hse pu Colds gy 2 yall Mia ely Sayde SL sel Cy Gels OL se odie arse po ares 4b Coed dates Oy 9 Ugly (fel yl teh LAS padi ySery dle Lyles 4555 dol, dye tds ole! ipoy Lelaely L5W Leyes CLI eb Legs cb LeU of PSN hide Uy ghl ae!" Ob OYs) sill WU bese dd 92 Yay sll 9 Oa yoy Gorey dale Sash al al ye Lely lotus cde ail 3] eL.at st 25! fi al eles! ld ey WM Cael Wy ey PHEW, Gobel YAY pall Je cel SLIT epale JK Sled! dad 3 iy pare” da J Hy caldce YI Lis Soy I 29Sea dy, 2 Le HS oy Oneal Lele ceva dF Ll Usb ge dee LEN OL abbey GA goal dey HIS cy ob) LEY U5" pend Cad A QS OLS! LF oll Ow JE "Lo" JUNI LOM SS Taal! gle Lyi pity JUS Uy} op Y asl] AS SLY! Obs) clas Uy sbie (gb Loslezel yu be a ELI Yor (I LISI ode of AZAN GUY arcade Ghy GUaraly caltedy Ebiodl BES erg GU grlredll add sled ya ELEY Bob OES pLacal of Ce WIE abla ONLUYE tie 1 poe” ots OF WY Jyty castle ie 135 (yo 61994 cay al A thal 25 gg 9 AU SW he tee FEW yl OY, (1) Gass py Lee 5 al Jl shame chy po dL BAN eh pe @) V6=15 yo 61989 SI dealt Lat Sle ladys oly pte 666 jasll dares BH Cay 53) tee Wel giles tee Mb yr gly Eattly BAN" OSS Bd 109 2 61999 hyd 616 stall call tage Utley Mlle ds GI pall LAW Yoel IU yoy Js 5 yo 1989 JY dal cipal! e gaabadly es2l5YI jou ol pte 13slislly Lal colebie J ag pt ple pats cheb y ugly Lal AT Cpby Me CLAS glee dal Me 5S olay Gu Alas! abs 3 dle geet MS oe USS Ey polady SVs le Latha BUI! ode Of CO rl GW EAU, Labldly 1 Sail OLIGYI JS Ry 6S Ugenadi Sng 5 alll oda tous Sy prall TE Hole cenit «Su sbl shll batty SLIT Es Sata gly a thal dy al AY! ul 3 "RE Comal (> aod! Die wr led Inet le ee " B sale Sey 8 Vy Obj bd 28 I LW 4,8" CASI I bina yo 25 Opt coe eM gaat od! SL all By Lee Lia lle Ql pated Ge peal gy A oe Le algetles gal dimlll ste (pil dyllasd! HB O39 Sl oeal! pol BIS go gS pb GEWI Qube Uyb Os JES ales ab hy shy GL lary pay Geel bh... Spell CLS ole chek cs) 5 poleall Lee} 3 EW 4 alia do pl of p play OMS y Fae gs slip gber gill pW Us GLY ULS got 3s arbre! bby aAgtlay Gylaall pals poh he al dee ge BB gl ge CoS PSY By GES Ee Of - Catt oles be gh bl BA Mog day dill dy pl EAI LT oy ge pl Lie OLS gle Lestat PLSYN & hi" 5 pall Lares pra OLN he SL x i" sf cay MED Lange ee pel gd BED dale OP ASE ge gy OM gable Spot pant 99 gal 7 ye a sSde at ypall Ly feats BN yoy dys (D (Sa Sle) the Cie LAU 3 bay925 3 poled BLU obbeW" ss Sos (2) 2142 ye 61994 gp [pl — eale [pls 4y 3 ould ny ySIl «22 tera Thee lls) the OBIS ol FG atl lilly plas pleat!” seal tome (3) 214 ge 1991 oid - Cine 65 oaall (OILS dl shenti (4) 14shh Ga B tl Gldy Holt i pre da sla p gly! al eee led op lS bb oly OS aad LLY A pall ASL C Lye chs} May EBay Noll BU tr sy cprdall glpally dil A] G5 HANI AK PLEYN Ey OLS pLlasal O15 ALIS ae Lay UF OUURSS Lane pe Lol (SY plo be gall pel ob ge las [gi] poles GLI pead ermay ce cpl ple 3 Yrs y 3 kel bls pteYl cGtSYl WBS Landks Vows laslecely BEd le pel JL of - Std Lat Nalye pl herbs Lie Lgiey obit oF I ope Tell coalaad toh J Se cle RS All Of pb gy Wa ge 2% aSlyg ale DAY gb Castilla Slee yo ELEY EL Jai ps Pe CBE go si Uke pu ALS! Gol pay GS pole 3 CW BE ge Fy BW Of dy Lil sie Jriny LEIS! oe oll BEAN gl) O glaatell Op bb!" 555) dy Jy HLS hy B bil Pe hed glee SYM Get SL pte, Geers WO pe rater D gaat ot pe eG 9S US Ger Ue JS 3 VI Shey lee JL BP peed eae BB lie Lad i, Sill LES ope Sats IS fy ol _ SSW Lie Heal Gay debs al] oolLG a bUS le Wis ps tial - ele AL Ebi IS Cae LM gL Gd 5 eal lt alse Gy bhatt Itty yyleall Ol ys Ul is ie L an Cer Byte Ol bly By th kee os ane Ley ol SY, YY tl Lal” (pleletly Blobul (3 Lil uy ybes Mee on Bales IM cle > toll py ib IG Vy dela B NOD yo eye eb see wally Baty BAI" Sy dy (1) edad Lal egg all UN 5S yall chase lly ball - 1 - GLa ad Lm JI ne ab (2) .257-256 yo 61995 (JSyVl dada cory 15Lege (lial! Jolie Used cgaly> DWord ge Ley bbls cals ud ULas fee dl 3 1 pall obtbally MY ys all bE lS oP "SES Gly ge as Maas “aptly "Gaslallly “eile” : seed Bp "ALal"s caaill pnts sled ge ll AUIS aS obey LEY! Ley PLee Wl Oo} - 1 aly Gil ope GLY Yost JOS gl sled! GW I] rbd Ste, Beall oF LS SEM ge Gulandl Glyn! Jee ebay! of HU dyed OB AU Las Lady Lt ole GLY! pall dpe pels Raledl Leylead sae Vi dole] le gyhts GBlally LSE all SIAL, BS) SLEW ge Way Oj 8 sly cfelélly GY LAND gellll apa deol! Gell OF nrtadly GI OI pd Ybor AI oleludly dU oe ad Uap Ue ES pall Lig et tlene 2359 BISA yi B tl 35" GPs Le his copailall le Od ye Vy plbeall Bb) Obie! sity, LS Gand! > Be gpl Sill se WY Oras aly Lagnling Willie Lowe Taree pay SASS Aske" 4 CLS! YY SL pbldl cy A ote Y ob Of td ySeF gl Asal Ug Maley “Lae gl" aby ol peall 5S Aad efolissy dala gl Lalas fold liso Lis" Nites «taal pgpae ood OM" Syrcdl Gls W3y Syl I WG thy 3d OY OG! Bgl Coll pl dLty als aS pba dey BV ode ge Le nbs BY gp slyly LEY le ts BI OL jael Ab igleedly HL PAN Sy Ob Co ia zoel WY LY Olan bl dell Distance "Lol" Uyliey Jol cl slizVi gl Négociation "is jist!" Vag pd tll OB call ait 642 gall gals GA" sd pe HHS Sy = Hla J ell BLE 5S pall eghadl By pliall Ghee iaijly gl o> gle (I) 36 ye (2002 Jy debit 129 116 Gyo ceeds (2) 16Ogntlize By cd giledes ol bY] She ty ol Bl ye ede Nps Lab: OEE Sm Go sléll le Opeb yp We Sb peKly Operate Bry LOD tad thea 2 PASM ple Andes slyoall Spel oo 14 Sill Sect 5555t ery Aled La ylesll gio y I BUIL elie VI cle Olam Ne ab yy Sul oA Nea Warde lf els eI Y gall Ola ly Gettl ll GLY tb 9S > edi Nel eA ll Gylaally U Sal slau ce BB sb OF Oey OMG dey Coe Vdey V" ole JI Le regi Badace Ub catty OF le yl cote Gl edly all Ye WI Lael godt of de Saal lis oat Wy Joly Gb He dl 25 Y ego I ce Bad OY AU OAS ae Gras y ill eS etl fl JS, dels ble ot Bll de game Gaile cet Wales ol gil Gale) ZSLSY dey iy pull ob ee Leys CO ered gl} Ole oe ab yey cles Jel yill 35) GL bY dyed hangs pd LST Gaal Laced 5 Loy dds yy 5 Lbs US cm By Eadie leareall ops ope GW Kw Yislrel, LAAN fogs ty ll ole Jacl J ae ler 26) boa Uy GL gw ABE y lal! 3 Goad, He aah 5 a ol Vy oLiall oo pte Slow 3 ile ty CSS A VW ue Vet aa ¥ Lies Bust sped tle dye yy GUN gall perl 32 pe La Sy awd y Michel Meyer: Introduction a Aristote, Rhétorique, Paris, le livre de err BM Set ll Ga 5S pall pA ple tess Lol J pel Gidle Mas ab (2) +20 yo 2000 ah dedall ela tents (3) Song Baa Nag tie 13 SH eal US «tall Jol ga IIyo Le Me ab (4) 8 Ge «2000 Jp of olantt lu! yard Chel ine 17Ob OL Lal b> pray Unser” fre GY at Latta GUIS 13] BS AT oh HaS> Al ob lee ye Bd gt GAS, pay OES teely> ope Lamy pods ably oye leper on co ahd SoM OL 5 OLS pial ge yall pte Wal Bal till pA Lat Bly gS By Lobb 4 jbl renee steel gl Bld oof pe gyal Ola Gl ee IM gall Stal BE BEM paar Jib gill oul SILAS Leys coy ghiy oy gli falye GAS s ¢ pial! bie dod ee Sales walsly aagd Grated Gola ge Wad Lobe! ales Le Betene Bpblell le Aecbel EW LS 6 3l tde ol gs CU lie SF By eal Le Jb I Lr beedly Gelsyl OL al Lg AaLELy ally pig Suet G bial B gulpoul Led! Lubl ole BOE ge gods [Rts 09S bee Goda dated LY! olla Geiwls bla eb ge ead AIS y Eales Fle) le pe yall dubs des aes Ee Ub Gl Idler ly lps Cts A Le rtEll gal eaile J GES! cal wy Eee Yede sshd il det3y! UY ge GAS vast Lhe ele OS Ils AU Cp Was AS yp Lyle Sy TL Cat Gi gall OB a bUall well aL ge Geall Cabs UiSay Eyes! ole ody ws Glad ydlbwll Slyaly porgly SUL) Leber ole pl ULL Baby Be le oi Lia 3 egal JB iy well gt erbedls AT 0 52 SN 612 tdpeat (aed 3 LHe) Dr of plaka lsd!" ol ot aot tate (1) 1360 yo «2003 (ysl «1424 pare eta EL we le a pall pos LIM EOL leo giles ordi aby (#) as Sins gal gn (GBM Gobo 0 lel Gabe Sls” 2 9S J yz pdt lena ee OB Gyo oy sSe "sb yee lly aay MEIN" “eS UHM Lt Yi, 12! 18MSS parcnly Su stdl ovell oul! Jas 3] Eel sypbly ol jes, Stall GLa Jels ole ogi Be GLT ghd nls wickey AS Yt Ejlisll oberg IY ell Ot Al ae sl aha y aad hae ob ELS Ibis! GUS ely yb Ly lly Lolyl ge Lis deplaey Wht olpobs frei bt ole pai Ups Sbtly call bebe hed Cle G55 pl let bee os y Lines YS yle B Wher] Sad Epesall eB tol Cus sel al ob peall Ul PI AB Bde Lad EBL Shey Coacal I eat ally olieall 35 FF EAM Bh ss Yale BAB y LLL la ygratl GIy (ye pall Jxal B ger MN ae ab 5 pS! pled] Ob aL se oye oy Y WU pets BB bs GB tall gee y gS Olin Dley pI ple day sIyoul asl ML Fgel gad BL po lle IS AS A op all oS Os peg EB gy “tb yall" Jeli bi! bead) UI ght poll cdl, (ill AbLA Liotly PASH LS atcall Sleeall Ge by “pS cole Ble 5 ded ol re COU gill GT La 5 O15! Vober oe 28 CI; Y 5] Croll LOLAY dy all BUI YF cleoul Spell dares 5 SIN clylay Dlem ge ab yy SI) lal geet bul — ~All dealell 3 ESE Oly agsliall S al ypSull Las, sail BUI Jil § auly JS Ete ne 19WY Aus plait GLelgudlt play aad 2 21CSM By Lob Akl OLY pal ol ank Olli his faty is pay LY gall tal gy Lies Lat tI GLI oP ll 3 PLY Ley ISI rail as Jp ned LU ell lg] dulee pew ISM Lowell JIE ge tole UO Bees equal By pple Heliy gd Ge EN NS ly etl oll gatas yl GUI Obst SLY a duke 45 pe BU Cont! UT st Bo bob! AY BUas IN ad Lele ty te «sla poll cLall 2 Le SE oye Clee Sled ecllb shee Ta Qo 6 CU Lonel Joey MS polly Glad oy Uy gall Glia el Ola g CY Bd Genes ad LI Le ge JW padlt Uf ee Ul day tole OH pb HUGS Jail Lie pling LY 6H dol OLS Gawain OY domes Hebel Lie ill Up byt Bales cle rail Le 5 EI Soeeall Sy SIS ty oy GL SSSI Ose gl GA SYA! BL Geabte wal Gale he jee Js GU oye AU peaill of ye 3 teole dust go rail Lie pes tbl gal DL J psy! doy clad az ay 6B gl GLBY! ES cle Yi age dykes GY) Comal aed ey Olle oe J Comal We fradnny gach gh h tall Lee tang Cle J Citas Leg hs (5 lass OLS 2 Lest il cle lle] Lgiagk LS US Clee! ES fail Lin 5 (sll toe AHN RolbdL, Lelsily AN 15 tools J labrador Sd, 4 So Wj sf Cee SG nl dls bi de a I Coe Lil gle 23el Bed Bact 3 Ubdl Yilily ae WWE byl Gblaly lied aU Sep aed Sm Sam Bly Coens raill Wa pater MEDS ager jules vege JB eLBYI bl yo pate, 4 galt syle oe Glee 24ZZ 23) paaaill sll Glaull a cli AZUL 25sSiglll #1 soll gall ahalung yg Glbaudgoull ABU gl) 4B 94) odd Ayetiiy! Quite -1 Waey chy Cassy BUasI EAI Co dtoadl Lyre bl ne gis SA Bye hs yly GLY Upem de JyVI Last de oy bil be yt ly BIL GW (Sy MLAY jot ols BIN" ty yiee phe og Gebel Clik fees dr gl til Mab y oye Ube! obs coogi Ley gl SY! Bab by Ld SA plead! Ep ab lye gS I HUD "at (8 yh OY 5) Spe ASL I> "Ebi" La ol OL Sle! Ue fs 485 HEIRON 05,285 GELON Opte ilis gs OL eb bass "I Stpae” slee] orl ye ESLU Boley peliiy OWI mg C2! A doy ots abl ieys Lele by Cot oF sey Ig pl otly pb AKL Gye CIS sib eer Y aslad Cll p Coa Zbl GS tend lee ped CIS de hal ge OLSbrest WE Cals LL Levatall SLeill obe Malai!" eal YelbY ejb OS (pally cg aileesdl WS ey goer L) gerlanly play he golly EbI in cle oF gd Boll oda BLT UT OSs a ep ys Corel be de (Ga ptoll apd LE pe Ist) 55 ySLee iB oh aeld "SL Sy “adil!” Beal Be) ST GY Utd de pS ypsll le Yasily Tisias poly (anys lin "35S" OSL LSS Gul sbecl ole jks frat: (tell Oy poll Mess Ab "vl", ABB glo gee pyar J telly Sleall gas "gee petal 27 yo 11993 Ast da oad 3B ye (She G32 oS Le pedi Leaf dad BWW yb Ys, (2) 27big lps leisy LSLIL Alles AUesl ABW 5] JVI Leal als OF GE poy By le jay Glo gle mat go bat se J il) (Cae My BILLY pede Y ads wo Vby co CGuly Goal eles! BLAS Lm fer gh AVL Ube le pLi} pa Le, Led! Cty allie VY] Lm gall HG cay gph SLES oper Jail CY cleat spend gb] ABI Law! ABI dagoy LSE eLad PSY Leds 48 CIS gt aL gal ols ad lea fally LEE le py OY Ubi ines dejkall Jw oY oe Coppilland gull (aloo 6 5 pciall -2 By ghl oY le OL gl Lash gl gly “tet Gy ol” Ley SY ole Gail Gye > “LN QS Lea! Ja a WW bse oad gall 2902 Cpl cpatlland yall Ledge glatin OI Jy Eyetly pt shenry ppder BU) lin pat sl lee sis Lesel ya) LL3] Of BIW! ole AY ss gee sh yp op boil dee Lay, Ula! UIs bly Habs de Way gullet Gad (J LS atl dp nad pI Ie ge tees nd SLI Of ailally CK ly DIL gery te bls! Bal" s OLY gall GL al 5 i513 dels Ud OL 5 tcdlland SI CL, AI Obl Ea) ge pb dey OG shoul gl Zot! OP cptele Ge to U Ai aS oe ej Geet Gill Gp Lal yay Hedge J Gully Addl Coal ol53) 3 Ll Ne olal gS) pLglh 5" se a pegblicn cr Ileal bale] eyed! op pall Sill le 525 "Jal Jil slog Spel erly gil Sil ag Jel gill Ll pay Lt 0,5 edly BLLY Eyal Lagll gb LY GF Aalill Sal aul by yf ye doe (1) +106 Ge 61976 23S dada oy eed ey GA lat cei ol el repent "gla I ce gees" ras ples 2) PEW EIS el 55 TILIY pally Olly G1 dase co pare salem GIL oe dl Il 251 1998-39 dns etal DLs eclnally BI GF oul Ges age 28Bole] J pdely cgetlland god) OW 50 Ge hy Ler seed yall Opell 4s LL 45M atl d pd YB grea LW Goa dey Ay Agel J BB yaad Qty OLY gd OU Ged tray gl SB ZLIY oy) ONG pail apd 3B seal Dye Sad th pd Bb pole BT py gatle d p O sad Osboel 2 I LW op tect E UY ge ead Lid oan ys 8g IE gy YI gle Gs oF ge WS le Jal ly ght eBoy PV Kiely gatlland poll dead ge ULYh legs le DL ata ni yt ol Lead DeLoodly AS Ip ole Lobb 5,10 ode $0 atke Oy Blland poll OS ASS ELEY WY patios Jill ob oy peel Seeded Sill ely 15) Sy Ba pally ASAI yb coer peed Cae pty Wyld pall etl pid Els! dle paslaseh teat JS gp Bjpetall UL, LSI Gleel, Sil olelas Let CLS praise lS iy Lg) clase VI ola], eit WG cgggultally lai oe dels ce gully CUM ue 3 ceeWy WIS Ly AST yao SWE Oglarty Ly OWS Oly LSI Line gd Ce AB ge le payya bey SUS FOLEY Gb oe” "ES Olt Spal, OMe passl a SPAM td Gyles! Gye gles! Jyil OF OSU nd pall cel Jal GB pra Legg alice VI Golo) UL lel ye Sf bay 5 pe Sh Le “tM ala od chal als 635 _BWly sdb Lyall OLY! Jross Wesley “LSI Opam Of" bh ad lad pl yybeall yay lrase Jot ON Steadl Jal Y Ji) Gleel Laty Leif - 2 ,ily Led oles gr 152 0 Seo gaat ue cleo" 39 yo 6.3) 2 Racal pe vd bead slo egy stig sys HEN : Plato: Protagoras-Euthydéme-Gorgias-Ménexéne-Ménon-Cratyl, traduction, notices et (3) notes par Emile Chambry, Paris, GF-Flammarion, 1967, p. 181. 29DY] gSay V Laglis JS Lolo cog toes tpn Hb gl Jill Is holt Keil tabs loge oo gt 3 lily OS 3 preadl Tidak ablS I ce AST OLSYL 5, yatlland yl Le J yily Sale 6 Sait cope gl sf ol 2Y ge AS of Olas ing oe Udy LY DLW ge Jou aly GUI 33] SpE GVLraly p ASI Le cred Ol pties Opinion HL Bsl eras wry Gad ES ob ony OM gated poll Ge od WS ny Wylde ULSI JAG of oi] ee US JEU pats OF Ghat LS Gol pat, Ot gen Geld Gobsal” ol 1 pce! HRN LOY] Cpoveadly Lge alll LLailly LSVG acely gl ape 5p SS elas ph DLW y gd ee ot be eal LU Le oye Lt Cd Ge Bee ly ALY aly Le fbUy lie GL] JS oly Le ye God nt OM gE IS olay OLS plo be ye yd yell JOU Gar ene ys Make feu gare de gh ge Mew wil ed Bf HLsebigy Ld LS (Antilogies) Kaikze boll as I gatlland pSl (gel gid leis os AL ie ead gf Gly dye IU Gru abe J ols | dado GLESY gags V" gle 5 J Whey LEVI dled Levys AF 2 UI 5 UO) oe tery eM PLT os py Ob OF ppleey "earl! Slee Heal shoul lle jou dinindl WU ols YE Came yb Ets woth dourcell oye sll de Yess ep boy! BL BU GE le Sts atl td pall tte oad J yill Laie Of aoole Ready OUI Gy Cloud arg Iydecel WU adlculy ad] Spiel Cee 989) LSS gle poll etl iy etoliny Jy! GUT Gd J BLA de gs Wha har ple" IS Sf aad Lig (re! lie dm Gals & 154 yo 1980 was Denil pty Gal) par Lag yb iy) Ga iste teow (1) Jb ALU te JUS; 509 alll 2) Lasel LLL asl Bos =~ (2) 65 yo 61987 J 9V dell wo aall clad A lag 30Chieti poled! clad! Ob bi of GLE by O'S Coy clo Od al obs VI sf grbredll elas p ggter arly SS ge Mead Soy V gated yl GUas [22 joo GU stSY BY! O} Gh" LRA y bl yal ee WBS JB adel FL VET B rlrage JE May qeteall Je LLtly alps ple oe “pls Uidow oe eid cle He SI ge URS Of" 13g ttl Ob oul By gles WRB aes Go) chy Bb lll oe one de Lhd We 9 Upill Oar) Yanai yer LL! pSodl tesla f Yi b GrEly dolara! Yblbsy LS! CIs Lily He ANS Spat od pall LelSY! Le yleall OB eclece W OLAS le pS has AB BU sll G6 SU OL elyerl, widely Gl) & pe tabs Be Seal Gy ELD oyperdl Sed Oper ge ebebsl OI oll! OLLI abe ST Conky GU Uppland! geghed bhi de gete CIS Gyattland pull gl ELBYI Lajlee OY Pedy a rall pra sere Op Ss poplar pole giles opus & GB Gad Olam sl he eS cael GF Oy LIM LEH tole CH) edly Jal Ogstaby SN IS Aw gall BU BY oS] pil gall Sal SNS Blan poll stoe, OT Mae OS pd MSs OM Was pl) opm prom Oy p5 Sipe JR tee sly Oratio SUN 5 -SI Las Ape Ae abs 661 ye Wy She Cent ee clout" tel ple () Oswald Ducrot: Les échelles argumentatives, Paris, les éditions de Minuit, 1980, (2) pp. 18-21, 27-29, Platon: Protagoras... Op. cit, pp. 181-182. (3) ADU Cleat Ob pal cged “Glee bal LABS gf Ha" tayare golem (4) 138 Gye Se od sll CaS — Cage LN fb SI ole geal TIS 6 JU gdh SAIN egy eggs Oe Me (5) A171 ge 61979 65 dal 31dasiell - (BB 946) Soul sf od - Ole dl gt JVs - alk i - MusbSI - EB od yy pee LU Se JSP JVI FS oL SY Jel ney gas bans plod YI Of GLY Janay DL Ging 4 5 oad She TS" Lye OF le gu 2ld cgling Slur sabes cgatlland pol ge Jr MIS § cards OF OLLY ghar plas days ASLAM UA dandy cI Gy jk Jy! Ley +5 Of eral forty J ytall et ge Dead bla poly Joli lata, Ob Latte OS AN ESI Olilbeadd ye gases yal dal Fe Keally gee Y Lalas! Ul pall as GH 8 paler LS OM" iss Py oddly Let de Sal gay Lydodll Sal IS IL CPIM Blows Cee Byte I OP cyaSthd WU sleeY! abel Jl egkSYI EAS Lam jol tgoleall Gls! > posal pplel op cel, 1B PE Ue oyee Gale Gath clo datas Ulae Glks JS) at cee, (Antiphonie) ole! slay J pal" - Lily Gisaiy HON diibe 5, le os IY Gait be te YS, Ayla ALA cll (UB oly Bay poy RIE oy LS 36 at BL 139 ye She haa BW 4b Ys) (1) 66 Ge to gSde ala 3 I? reg ee 2) Laat ll gall Sal Spall dad ZS sf Otpelly DLUI colo JI ne ab (3) Ogrcdly LT gad Lia G8 Js Gl fea 61998 IyYI dell oye . 83 Soadall GJ} 33 tial oy 0B pal 32Ot Ertl olay lye tl B Bylilly Bodl ge yy ALS) ehaaty vagal olatl gf "pence gla goeg begb pao gw geil ns CH peplelty Goll ole UBT ULERY pseie pgs - pall DV le py AIL sleet Gp ne Sy Uskrall agli] - ON yatae del gy ARID AS Go She “plan 4b) Lil Puan" yo gle (1) 33gyglallal oie gtd ad 9 dada ob cgitabll glaall ide gghriil Jalad bile (A -1 ctl pall clam cy ELEY ALE gps Op brs GS ye frais Y ppl dey pte 3 le Gl Al Latest dele Gla ye dole Lat ge Uyjre 4S ol oy Gb wi Chee Ml ay otal” bbs glsel Sey Y AI ST well coral gd Lyte SsLasdHs os prnel bjleal ge bo gal Ladle OLS op pV 3 MLalill aye Ate LItte o boul US esl oil SE Late shelly “LET Jnana d eott ays sil LY Ged pd Yb tale ob hal yo We Sg be giles ore "pig gn! diy 3 gM Jp! BS" I Le el GIG De tee Obl Jor Gilpll Ls 3 405 pLe Acgospatomi CAS cpl Jay DY pra olla Leo TY ab el cgeotreall pb BL AS pall te Obl fro HUY La jLzel gs Yebuk tel cy ode ON jas old Lpolioey tcyalland pull Lgrandy AY ey gece! OY ls AI Galt gd pL ls seed] isl, DEM satay sw po Yale] SIE oe GSB "JES" Lin ge p5bsll lyst 03 Ogbrl pra ViSiny igiodly fially plat Ajo BH ge Lalas tall” p ebi Sik ye IS 5 Wc gadall Cacreall le LAY! Lage catle te del. cepts cays jay dard ys bl ye JS ppl Y] pL Jy pL LAU BK Claw gal Sal 3, Sul pds Le J hal ge ol cpap oe 9 ye (INI tell Gall! eae Gyles jlo hati! 34A pgied plese Gheel Opbl JU 4 Sal) EbI ee Vy delat gs IS ody gobo ging Dsigleall pry Laill aging WGA Gil» del pry sd edly Og NpIl pry ch YL I lI AY) CYL Hy Gly Bolsa of OY cagbol GU Lai ye al gels ple Caalyy gatll yl tals 3 oF EM Sy ggernll Gb ye Lgl Yosy Uy! ped al els hi Se] BIW OF UU ge bat O90 Cll Mig) CLe a) Grady cel 5 ee SE ty LB E15 ENjMy IE Er UL) ye ly Meee ee lel ply LB ge Jay Ail yal LS pS go5ell LBV Le rere (pl pI ALLL 3} ake Uy mrad a ybyst ce Sly Gl eerpall oyare plrare egil yall rds ake Lal lis Lees fold Jaw Late Sled! Soy Late bs Ale SVL OL fe hl ge gil ely GIG a Lee CO b3UT ee Gils all Epasl iy 2 La slat icledl Gil Late ol degley dejle Dy yoo GL 3 cody TIL VY) Lele Gin Y o boul 258 op ptt ILS Od OMe Loli! ib sl gape) Old J qe Gel tLe ol" YY tal Wail yally lial! JLuly gil yell LIS dees 8 SE cadlla b U yill oe sl Aloe ALN Gai el gy OF Og dTT ail “OLS LI" xd GM staal Lpeel equal OF 8 Brad Ob Ly sol 5 0 pS SN IS BB Lady Jal] Uyo etre OPI OB eyes GEL SS Goad ob gay deed! SSL YI ell ball ely eral LU cabal yay pall dey y2 Jaa ob Fad OSI Cody gh le ed (All Glial! LIS Gis ay" Vy +1980 AH aa 6g ps alll sla eile Lo dal! Uglas Logbl ype 3,T (1) 90 ye 139-138 yo 61968 rae yall USUI No cle 55 old Lee 5 chy ygerdl 10,L36T (2) * 35gh Mall” ye fill ppd ye oF di ely OA de i gil Sal Sat" of Ls cial gh aye sf ptt JS ge tS pl iil 5 tlio GY Gad Gy oly LO} ce pagll pw poll OF LS "sald ass Gidolyy Rely Ha Tied! Cla be oggh sl sf GBI Gals fal ga “Jest” Al page” Og byl Lee Lgl) Lye by toate 0 pS nd pall Lay pad LS Y ee AS Al pledlly Qed Syl oY bw od! 53 Y GUI OLY UeSodl OY aL Ma VY] GileTL plat jae Y oybral Ley .dssthsy II pr ELAN od Ey geld -SiU pardory Gala jell Lyle ep els o Dial god Lys BaF y Galeodly jsut pos APY! BLS Whi GeV! ee Qa oS etl Of" OEY 3 Ey ster ole Gor of Ocala dally, Oydiied HAM! eat, Lie Y] Mabe oye Leen Gia U ya ple GI] Metis ISO b9UT OF 635] ake oF (Sal B een OF gb Y ld USF ales og LSet op Alll elas veg le le Med ges Gh 12 Jal Op bl Lares ely yt ill Lb! SLUs oie ye Lad LAM gs Lee ipl] Emile chambry seep fear) Cath egal yl) LSI gp Larde Jy ii yall We GS] ay ggerl Gabe oath Al Led! Gi pecbell Ey pally bl ae oiled cry ested GB patel am yok Bibl ee N ial fe ry abdul ols ad capsist deel ye Ql BP gated spt Cl be Soll by pnall ste] lad 22d ie Late Me Ke he tee al got Gill BLE pul GSI Lol l pdle Kabl G ll &paall Lag ll Se ASG I Ld Lad tgael teoly opm cord 55 () 128 yo 61980 8 BS ety MOLLY Gadd gla WL ye gl deg MEW GI] Joe payer 2) 221 yo 1983 - 91403 4 Sadat) cy pr 4 SLAY! ABU Go cy sScbe edad LW Lad gel dandy oper Gers 55 3) 122 yo Sie TL Jods adder 4) 36ae) Ob HT OL ST oe 2S ginny opal i BL oe OI op Kaa SOIT Naples OF LyaL TOs M50 Gp Koll ge (ol S Aor only ale CL ie A Nyakead Lad Lp ob gy cleties TbLderll pag c+ 7932 He Rte ab ly ty Gpnly lll GG OLY! I foal pales ah Ll G51] 45 Sole idee obey ye UI) le et Ge tl elas Wstaly Lenka! le Op bl dads tae Qe I Le Oo) MOL p29 teddy fates bin gich Of JS pl pid ize ade SLE TY) I ye oh Ges J le pee ly Ga any SAS AU! "GLa" “Lyell” Gow OS Ld by Wade cae ald! LI bogs st al JS Gok bles ted pull OpbouT ale LS, Lazsel SL ealyily cadet op Wsles gy OSU sy II OW pl ab da) SUN Jo ct ol yay bl jie dead Coded cubale dpall dale 2 tld ded! lLaall ye Bale ails La tN Agel yell So, boeb > Gi eV Geol CLT eels Ere hg Seep lST HL gle alll yb Ge eeb ey pall nd pull pela cola ll gs Dee > ib oT IE Ge ge OS Cebiall Lbs y gill pol B45 OPV] Uy Lael! (5 CU pple La eM gay Obl ge Jpod CHS ol Glbel te alge y alge LEG cetyl Dyill ob gh AUS! Obl pel WUT fb 09 DEY cle /igoball Eg tall "Gepes" a Glas O15 MO} Radel Oly” ge QUAY derby obey ye tyler Ul greet Jel cel Oral BE ge Oph HT Gat ye) Uae os ehldy Gola Ussher Oy ANG 0 6 g5de RU gS Gadd Lad gael deol ope cars 55 () -Platon: Protagoras..., op. cit, p. 160 (2) 37EF SIV CALS BB AKT Dy ybwally fete clred eles (yetland y SI HL coed) 25 GW OB gated pI Utht J pailly Eye yall Ob be pad kde YjLill Jee Coppa gull AEDS gh dl aki gh Gules se Brylane -2 9-8 387 dy ola ge Bales GU by Mss SRY goer dee oe diel gle bide els Ail by peal ena Glo ow Ergbeall pals woe cell ope OS shy glicall ple rye pt ea ebay wBygloeall OWS By (5 427 dee Shy "Eat 5 SLU ably Gob ge Gey alas! pd Opals Osh J OIS LS ad Ret) de 1S Lob pole ah BG ey bie eo Hal Tye OU x OI colo ISIS, os genid Bybee 8 lee LS > Ql pbs ISIS dpe LaNbl gad pl isbedly ole dBW prey Ue bie oleae Us ele ise - Glas GLSY poles .¢L3] al gine y, SUSI Loos (pS get ES poll ME pny "Uabdl" b ope "UI" ped p> tLe ols ad OL LBM DN ergber bh in i Garey este bli pom gil eebet Gye ASL Oe geal Oly cal ge Li Jes Jal o-» ill YT ST ty GUI cy obs ye oped Gas 2 aely oF Lee he UZ IS 3] wee ae pb IRI OS Reda yet lB all el oda Daly J Gady ay (Gatland yl ot Pla clinsall pl sel Dla! ob Lae ASS Yer la Wildly OL bhi Coe eb BV dale le yi deal dnt OT gm od oki cd HEU) (SUB og HI Oby cs iT pm OSI gle Ope pe Gy! clin Ob AUS ge bh ae Ged HW) at go Leify SIS ty LS Le LS colbstl, pSlly Madly Y) ol JM GU LS tell gb Gis Y dol JR BASS Nglenriny ob oF Gay (BLAal / ilird oli) 1 55 smbool 38OM gk ge Ya tI bee] BU) ge Ot” La LIS BY as wgSelly JAS YI] Ge ge ld Gad Ge! Stes ob Lia. ye WU bike US gee Fgh ye BLE ye Eula BEY Spi Ul sel ppd lille pata ae BS LT Y 3) da pat Jal Syl af PM dll Gb Gil tll Mis 3 Cale ob Oly a Ble bide Sly Lgitliny OLY SL St, Li) ener pe thea amy AU po ye Antes Lyle Gly ae glad ll of taal pls] Opts) atal” Yio y Lolel ote ay ollasll ple Yl 6S ye AST lee 8 geblyally lleeall gd Oly Steel ON Kole OL! Jord ola pLIY da. Ob Lees ple Jsy bbe AS i pe GA Ley WL" SLI O5LESLy Coal ite LVI OM gece chs Fae gl oY Cod Sts!" of bie joe ple ye OLLSY laiy ee ade gil di all drys oar V Lge tall eLayl of Lis O"eLay Chee Nia Ob ity bh de Of fp gill 2 OURS ope df sotey pis LOMO Baas Vell pl gh eg gerd! Ul” YS oF gXey Y alu BB y Le i pall Qe Y bhi om gate sy dl cle af gy, Glee La OB wotslely LEAVY bigs slice pl Ley olizeY! digas Jil UIE ge Lo Ss Bi yaal) pats lll ai gs cles! bl ie oi] p Sky Aplail fo, lbs! a3 Del Coy Ca: Way ole! hg yb ye Lanay store Slew le Abs B53 bli USS LSy Platon: Protagoras..., op. cit, p. 157. (1) Platon: Protagoras..., op. cit, p. 172. (2) Ibid, p. 176. (3) Ibid. (4) Ibid, p. 185. (5) 39Cs oe Legis Legler cad) Gill he Lge Ep dyghuall GL 3 6b Voy hae pd ge Leake UT Lge V en Gy glade "335 JI" deat gly By decal! YGite ob GSI) Giod Yoculs begat gh ll oy PFS tly Jad acl WY pols bla > By dol ij aed cd ope Lely WLS Gad tall Lig pty lee ty Lgl ey Ogio GLI Galse aI Opin V gp ilete 2 pre Lyall eLohe Rydal Fale Gis OLY! as gl Lied! OU ane ol Cow pnb Pa daally tally asl Lab sly ball oe day) Lidell 0 pill olay gles JStay Cail ad Age ody ly et gl “ol jleall” ye bss Gedlly pSdl W UiMe Y habe /ielus SLijles ey VI Opi ols cos Sy Ca gl Qa Lab NM cody cabal Gal Chl cosh OLY ley ils! CAL gl cosy TOILETTE (ps dy sldaSly FLATTERIE Glas pte py La jlaatt oda JS 3} ARIE 1B eal pall ye Ble Uplery les "SSI Gay BU pod anes” aS jo yds cgedall ots Lee Gale Lee cr gh QULSU bl aw dled lay Vy cod dh fess Y Stes OF WS holy pl UUs y edall 15] WS SMAI (ge Masala deat mail ob ales OP all Geel atte Le AEM ye Lb galled pall elas Clee Corn ol Glagel ge Yas pene LSM cles LS le bie fore HU OM bene EU)" SS Lrt—~S—es=s—C ‘= wreaks oplel ate LONGUE] y Ahjz AST Vlis gpd soll Was 8 gis oF ghey pT, Lb ST lie LY poy hb ab ad plajS Coded olny pS bla oy ye ge JS els Clee 48 Sle Le bi iw pte Ody Lely Na J biden ge Y" syle Jy leche aly Gy tod! Wale 45 nly J dell oval as dl Bye, ola) adlie & Lead SUI Cyl Bul eh led op pets gill Gol belay Ly oI] Lee pe by clas Vy 4b po Y Gets Mie fey (Gatlall Byg et ebay} oye we Ui, Ugenii Bysledt JHE ESL bhi yy OG, dead le daty ailyey abel BLED oul gs gl dl aii ye ey Ctl Lie ge aol sl Bil lee pala Sy -(Colsd Gudery Ade) Gebl tye ey oe all tle, pentl oT tue SJ accl Gy" dye Wes We pte BU Gal 04S Gye OM ree Ob Ser GU ytd) Las 3,1 ll Ad aSaly Slardy Crley ptt pill J atly copee Obey GAL Cte Bf enna 2S yall” By had IE Ge ait Ue orl T bhi Ge pee od Po gerbe tly SHU Laas em gylendl OS pall ype ELS tt segodly dlardl ots CO oF earl Yad Gd] Le pleat IE gs Obl Lad 4a Rao) USS ey GU Gy Lall clam gh erbealy copeall gatlland pull Dyk gt be ial pate oF aud! drbrod! Lajleall ole byt a be Fob ral cal saz! BUSS OF d99 ley ye poly Fd Gow Vilyyee Jyill gee gf Cubs! Of Ext OS UM bia J yi dbs y HIS Bas beote, pram 15 O,S ond GU gpd gall ge LV yE G8 of ay dh by Latte Slgs Col AD ye tent (1) 129 0 teed (2) 165 ye tendi (3) 42et ober ci Gall ye ded OY Go xt WU AG ll ole py ad ods (Glin Jab J! ss” INE gp Obl ee Za Sly OLLI Sy hily HL je Grolt 0 B poll ocey OIL ses SI WG Say Glow GY ull obLiel last! ye oli rr ere le oly Lala I] SUI egies 055 call at uss all Suis 4S Gi fey ill lll lene ye oe lll obal cp lal] Gene 92 Cle pb yell 3 A sill pgebil O sled SI get! aid Gl Clee! Y} a 6 Obl LU ole, EUYE Ly raed oY GOL" ssh bis bla yb WS ge) Ted ns pill pay YL ear Y Oli sh de pats Ju died Gps Yo OLS pte ONGHEM ge tad gl le gkte Y oi Al dp tee 5 Cee ales bid le ate Si, OybIGT > LIF AAI ALS (46 yb ge pols yy LIES gold de bilan del ad dbisuy ule dy le Lisle el dl age Vober oT ye dyke" 4] o> Gi Ig alésl, hts Etre elped oe Gilad OYLEYL obo foe YO". gb bi jaw pan WS GENS 89 pall Le J pill og pL /plisl ai.» 6 GO pee Se BS JRF de US 2,5 a!" Cow Gate JS al Of OM yds ogy ee ey oe SY be plat Vy oly ets Y toe Si BLA Wb Mey ay hyp aa! coy LS 3 bt o bol gr gll BLS dow gb IT OB col gee Gly Ue Koee etl nd pl AE CIIS 13] BLD U3" Alls ad ashy Gest Rte asd AST Ue wath 55 yo thn (1) 274 0 3 35de lar! ge oh ssl db! 2) 100-99 yo ans (3) 1108 yo tends (4) i (5) 43OMS aEM dauly yo yisl Bh cqmerelS Gerald Upans gl gy ctl 5 pcebl Spal E52 yO] Bp PUG Haba) ULSI Bary BL y Lert sl G3 aay lhe pe dary GUI felis! gh gal ll" UB] yo B jaoll old GS al Jolt OY cys Ba atl tll Oboe od My "Ub gl phy > sill ell op Dsl a aS ey Ce" OL HL Ye phy elas Ol for Jy OM" land ply Ltt Gp ndaill pd poy teeta! oar Late, ca elizad JyMI Az yall Gb lordly USI) Come i pelea at ABU id aglow cy gga EUS hy Denil! 5 pone! Leal AG poll Gee JStus as el ay pail be Obablly Matt or ceil Le 8 Ys pall Whe OF etlyg «gyatlland poll ebdasll 2 ObWwY LT i ya! at Uy BL Casall Be py Whey dada jad AS hy td ge Aly daddl, 5b poll Glas O| Tad LI ges Jedle sl al 28 ape) ese es WY IW Gy 3 Late yp 0 bt Led] wleadly Gouly Seeks pak ill all God GUI tall lle ae pe IS oe cell Ge Sf HIS Gb in LM bi We of VY] dail oll of gb Wl ease Gegeell Ming 0 Kb a lay Gee BLY WS pe Wad Us gy Brad JUS y plat ge Obl Le Juodly Jaedl Leb AB" ga Ob oT ae Joel oF Bl Gabby Gate Ay al fe Medel Gold gh tall ge eats Y Lied Cat HL, 5 bY Gal gb "Labo! ON 6 yi / Alas cil Ugly OF Quay gil olillaadly OY pinay «ill AU gp tax pall GG op) 96 Go Uni (1) AZ ye ends (2) 175 oy ta 95de yan) sce Cle!" aN ples GB) Hailed Lege tals gall be tales ders it SI ld! ee Le As #139 yo 61987 — 01407 JY dad oy, quills Aly Lela 44PS ae asld Tyglowe g5 ble My BLS "55 IS age” Jel lee Etec ASI Ga” le pyle Gat pita Ls SL ie Crs etn aad SU pel Sey > ULI a el feats aly He pd gall ee 0 ES ad" tl gen Maney "ed ae eg GA Lae age Gh eS gy wodlly Landa! Gels Bele eo Lbs ell Opler Obl ue Jedd OS Why Ong 3 Ob Gb Gat Ge PS SA oe ial J Ty tere 5G slany hele lon cgculuace Pa ps BEY oe pen oy ele Lapras lg tiles le pd gall pared polatiy Sill ,3 Lis pall ois Bae gal Jb ud) 5 /U 5 JS OpbT Ly by I SWI Ll all OF jsel AUS ol ey gyda Ll, aU GUaI ees fol ye cad sash fall Qa Vase Sp SWI /S sill IS > oye ary Wied! slacel Mido! WG ly allan! Hind! oaks di] pay [galesld yd 3 MO ane Lt byes So el AA QUI Gs Je" YY 1107 yo 63 Sie lard ye sh ypu :dsb9T (1) +106 (0 ctunds (2) 4ni (3) 136 Ge ty sSdle GIG SI ND GG ce yy (4) 45sft Aso soll Rolgall "ygile sally yale glausl cgpleall shu! gs phe ga Sela] -1 pri al Jeb qa! byt clay! ea! Le le 8 J BL LY Gene Gas JS, “Uy plead!" glare! alld ga NI Sbuly dol SELoL ley (..0 9b, gated NN) OLY] ale dilane tgalay tele els Mh 2 Yl yall bla 3 drat oll roles BH ye gel reel “yglby MI" JSta5 Topiques :avl yal! - 1 Les réfutations Sophistiques :45th3 y JI OLSSI- YS Rhétorique :4Uasd! - ¢ Orb sf Gh sh Y pldl JULY yas Gd olives ty Vy) ctl Sil) ple ela dials op bd! UT Lie » Analytiques dlgsske WU le Ju LS y rl GLinadll ie gaat sew! of B ABs polly Ebsdly Ward acl yl gl gl dt 2 JY-Y cod oul! de Les Secondes analytiques 15) oAJoull «bs oF eS oe gel! Jl Galil! SYA sl ih dl DY g cee gree gle BUY Ez beed olivadll ode J 4 yliall nail ad Hal EFL C..) JU gl earreall B gee Gad B yan je Ota” LIS TSSy cd SHI Yad! pletly Gard M5 pil Gad! LL OLS, Mane gh see Canty ail agg” lee a Ly BENS why geal gl Spl atlas Joend bt a als 121-120 Gyo ey sSde yet ace cleo!” si ples (I) HZ ge ee 2) 46slams A LIEV oye Lgnard ye Wad Legadlics cal} Oa! Gs gh (Les Topiques aul gall) ("Ling gall” tis -2 daa} Jaadl Bay Jo Uli wo Vlin OLS gs Lay ghall OLS Gitly aot ps ABW Dit hed te HLS le forty qr eps yes Sm frds oe pill Coe gf tel iy toed dhe Gas, OLad pte He NU DE fortiy bl oye Gly ola yo Mts wel Fy LL ABD go soley yall Lab Bh els pat Wd alae Sh ESI yay Bly Adal Bre ye Tends del giy ole gly SLL elds olibsall Byles A tall shal dil sel sy pall o8,YL, Bole I pad Her Ne Jats ay (cal fb bel SI UliSLy «arly Lol Ome del iy Lids OSI Oley SB GL Jel gy obadl sel a Gackt, Lole Jel iy A fT ol bale of JL Cols al Obs BY Lee Ip vee hall ot Gall jared tel sy GIVE Dols selyiy els Vly ote SEY told Ups pad Gad ole Jar tty Lod ,5 Lali! lial, Bodie LOLS ye Wad YT bepee Vlel fag Lob GUIS 1 Le Cidbreally Agltead! LIS Go yee Ge TaSU Asad yl Ob pall god shad gb JU ye BSL OL peal ye GLEE le Aertel Lel ally SBA elyly Pol YE Cilde gs Byth Lelsy et Sek voke yl Gy ap by Ghd Ui olay a pll gpg Leal! UI LI RAS) ep OKA ple pe Upsdy had pte dust le Jars ay Vad Sly Gt pl ford dels ge La aS aU Gop atl Ces 2p desl iy ad REY Lely rails pind Lele sel by baal + abe phan USy egy Bley ae yp SU ply aie Ggleet gh ib gk! (1) gD edt 11980 JIM Raga OES = Cay ep epi Io ory SII 47op Beth el gy lala) oI wy OS pall dolly gered dodly Gh Bas hts cgeteell called is ad LAY tel By cdgy teal! ol ll poll ASM Gajld LY tel By je eeall poe als estilo sls pF he pll ltl LAS Natal Ugedy WS pad Laat cle forts ay well J LI! Dist! la] shea yo Gal paral BU Ly SKE hy acl! UU] sel ya) deal wn yoo) dabseall gl Ba de bead ode forty cSt Lesher ood pry Lal! Ulett badly Lag pide bes bby dys pall Slediall Yd Ohad te Well grodl Byres Jornal Moly Le ga eres incl Bs Wad By Ualeall pes Bs Hp dbs Coral Yt alsa Oued) de arty Gyllad! le Lpaleall Mey glad GUS oye Resell Dds lay BUS poll OK LS de iy (PES LSE BY eb ge Ere sell B ASU LB od U5 gl shes Lay gly OSU asl Mido! GUS! ls GB Leable DY Jaedl jsel 8 ObIT UIs BL Sarl, last gens! OB Gell go He Djall oly pcb gay Pall Brey Ob glesagh gil acresslsly odteed yo auld Obl) prey 2 be pd BB pry Tey GL] OV Stig Sy og gll gid ty AS Y Ob J bly ILE Vy IY OV bee nd bls fo OLe JI LgaSow Yoke oes on shel je 9 oes a setalls V Ugly Bases pil" GMI Balai Olatiall de oalarel slay ytd - i iaypally Glo fae ccglall dpi alt Gelb yay Macy cpp dad Ae ah darn EIU J bell WSL ede tod ge (1) coh par cays Quasily Ally SLL WW dale! La jell dibs Lely hails eel 10-69 ~68 -67-66 :cslevinall «1995 ~ 1415 JM) decll 490 2 4 gl ejeull cy Sdle esha yt hte spall xd Q) 48ee ASL latielly OMG Clatde go aes gl" ya giz old & TW tole ot east ot Wl Geer Lely I" te “UaM pleat” MN RE SB dlls ogee Oar sehall sf cass of pee lp tele bb Ss Joel J JY af 103] eels ASB ULLAL Sed Shey eg pe sell tg gad tL b si dar lec ye ys Se ——————— «© Vil ee ares hrledl chee J ES Gil ys SUE! Lexa Lia of vit 8 Eis! tbs GH ONY dely Te Gs CLI sf ole YE" GE Y Balai Lat OY ol oY! Got (I) kL HLS Sey Vy Bale oll i dees Slade le VW Juadl po Wels OFS gel Ged Epally BU Lad fi Se OLLI ase of Lata Lee U pie PP oglded Wy lal sf LLadl 15] toll lye Coy uedl qt Sp sllastI Lin OB shut oy -Le Probleme dialectique " Juiz w sllasit” Physique nbily Bthique GY 1498 45 xe VL le gb ays vlns his rue gad ULaill yards Jpeodl hel Lege eghtally Ls,e f Definition > Lf 0955 of AS Y Used) SaaS gt Uyacutl ods CA sar tnalell pall (2 olny -Propre Holt I Genre Lx sf Accident Bs OM Sard Lai ge dase (a dl gall" oth eos oll at sl Dhar Sy dedie JSy oldie os PoBY of" yh l ye U5 "ssc gf Lee sf Loe 4,5 of LE ba lites (gall 3 JB ola Gali pay gh wl af BET AS obs loge gs JV daw OS LEIS La jou 489 0 enti (1) 490 Go «gel eplliant (2) Michel Meyer, Introduction @ Aristote, rhétorique, op. cit, p. 18. (3) TA yo 63 Sdn ARIS y ghee Nyy Jaa tall he geod @) ATA ge She AIS y gourd so) Jd rll de od donee (5) 1493 0 1 Sde esha st gle Ib shot (6) 49(Pia ody Le raisonnable gins Lew 3 Sis d ) pal" Less Juedl GAS god FT ee Why cok, OS gow sl a pb a pst Ley "Le rationnel Viggy oaths laced Lally Le bay ro Wall arb lpr zie of Pe JSS te steals wolalsY dates fp Lek Loblaw Y Lda besye pole Ite Jpd HL Sy obLie Vl by le Ja ere plu le duel op JYse I Jets” DYE hy pil enatll Slee OM aandicadl Spt Kal yall ley A] WAS Gag OLS lad! cle Gold! Gad ply pay geet ol crcl ed pal chee ciljleall le pats GN teyeal cLeoll ne rend parle) opassly “ate” 0. bol le it gt Gt ab LAB path ipl cle gael jou 03] be iyo AQJEY le bt LB, CEE A Slatiall adie OB Gyygte badie ge lls Jol IS Bly Lees ce 13] Vol ans” spel pie “Ql yall” oe GF rel Les Madly gb ol pe or Gill gael Epo yall bed oF Spd le Srkcal gh aL! Lady a gon ler Feely lyst GLEST O ce ebb eas Lee Lelia LLadll J Sal /J sill eo Bye gil sie! Lele pe of 1545 03] La Cd glrodl Sp al) Lael pw adley SelSY Abily ol pl quae, LS plana! ely Gjale SS Obed) ca) Aagde cogh cdely OF B Helly Hlerrel “cells qe Lai Yer dae BLA eal pall O95 HS Gy Lerleedl chee] me OSs Lie Le AUS fay Mole ya yell nari gil BY GLevly Lbs oly Les Tieux communs 45 tall acl yell” OF sheet J) sth slS Lab desile AUB Gyo ty Sd glee | ce Claes Michel Meyer, Introduction & Aristote, Rhétorique, op. cit, p. 18. (2) 726 ye SUSI eel Sd eg sT Ghie sale jet GB) 1120 Gyo ysSda .. dayaall BAN 1r4U BYy, (4) 50Oa ya dee hla UBT io y fects oP Redd LLadll Upale sas oF 6 gh, ol Ql pall ste 8 gla T OWS HBL heli Alyy cpcadl eel yy (oe pl edlyy edu! Cale tas equ Byte B lees WMI Cal sal ode Yd tee pil PY peocall esl ote al Silly Setly et sly Laps OKally BLAM y Ay Sy Leola po of babes Y bes Sos of dBW HW esl yall OLE 4 Of MILB, Veer all Lees eli Lamas a Alby qo dthy cLasial OM eddall ys S pam We ade a5 Ut Say tel yl Cex" cleo tgzbedl pots GL Yer y cetyl At] CHU! calls Lime, Chel sels te bo os SUEY ees gat Sbatiat fey Gi Lad! Ob set ouey op berode oath ne 9 gerd DVI Gebel ell poke gu hd CUD «gold Vy pla ol ied Lente!” cya oLEVy Lal Sacks aly ets] 51 yay AS A MI ted AM Ge Gull pg ee ally ted LD) A sab HL Ub ype ete gay Gol B ON stead! Vee Goth Gis Yb YI "a GE YI" CYL Of tag ole V¥szl ib I JY IS BLS HUI LG Se GLEL, DY Stadt JVs Ob Hy Baball obtdall ge Ley ayy pall clysetall ge oalees @Snall Oli! aillate JUV any cle PF BB fer OLS Obi dl Lavy ol HOV HL ye Gall Sold! Lola) 6] 3 Lely aed ol YI of AUS JY Las Manuel Maria Carrilho: Rhétorique de la modernité, Paris, eee ee cee Sart AU Le aed deory SI) SU Sle gal Cy Sdle glee t Glee Ub ght (2) 272 yo de 6 ARIS y ghd ye 1190 Ge sy sSde "gaa f ace Clo iM ples 3) 1507 yo 6 BU ejay Suis eget Ghee Jb gent (4) 51an op Gay bet ye Lag gpd Adze Dead I sacentt gl ALS 6M, etd ga best of Us git JOYS JS le ea + JOYE CAS oe Boel GAS So Ebleal Rhee Lal Op lisllyy pla ps = yes sou plal oye yalesli GB ae Ob | ce pats ae gy DY Ligh gurl GBS of or Al CYL plSY cs pats LS cher gybiVy Glaally LAU VL lal palin] Jy tel B ses] bode By grlred ball Le ly PS eS he lt gps daly YS jared gle USI Sully Gel) obsae Meet ge Col tally Geld pall cl sial BL he Tassel od La gs oltéa! cork bth Cals Ladi Ue SIEM y filedl SISA Hele Qe ole pd gall ly ly od ell Of gest pis Ve guard clad jailer ob Gull Ae rts qlee ieee Hd JS: Refutation St sI tl ot St pas cot ore bar Of GNI dag ST gilt gye Led] caches! OY" rJ pie Jarl Hard LAI GB Fleet Sobel 3] AW SB ld quel otal Jae) taba 5 pl 0,55 indy OLY Is oly Glade ge GAY A qed iy bts patil Eel pl OF GE by ily Ll J es (de dart Sl jf Lambros Couloubaritsis ..¢51 UU cys gry oad OKI ALS Qe By VW Y" cqiltsl claall of Alba -3 IgA gd ge gt tay ley ge esd OLS Jai oKeu Y cas! aL I NLT Spall ALM Ghul ge wl) Ylosy boul 508 yo 6 A ej eye cgesl Glan iyalh ged D Lambros, Couloubaritsis: "Dialectique, Rhétorique et critique chez ne Rae a la métaphysique 4 la rhétorique, Essais 4 la mémoire de Chaim Perelman, éditions de Nuniversité de Bruxelles, 1986, p. 112. 52gat Jas Gill Gagll ols ad AsU yt dyastl BGS galeall o5594 Pol Slee 3 Sot!” yo WE ay bdily jatle 5 pl fee Ls Coe soled Gell oe JS eres il or} al ches oda 3 ASU ON MeV qeredly plaill OH OV By Ulead! Obs shut hi iy BAS Ns yop By Lad pte Lae 6 ty I) Util! - MELE anos el gl fradty Ulbsdl a wty Juedl BLS! etl ce eT gb iS ead en hey dee ge 0 Sy UI TLL! - LS ChrtNy SrLtodly Syed!) LULU Bw HY Leyes el Medes) Slee) OAS gh go tab yall UW YS 2 6 Aedes Syl de ked shat Greet aad te ded Ugby SII Ulead ALS isl ely Oly galled pull Niglady chdlare Lila LLG Ler ye: Od! pod es a patll chro! gf ji tal geet Sys cela dm de CEM TY] AU pl oSh Glel of gle 25 el gy pall al ye Aly galls slay gnc lBY ge bby Glyde peut oe LS asl Lugs OY Jae! Guts SUSI" OF aires Latte _ als "UY plait" ols erga Lady thee ull Bae Ubi § — be pd le - Jos Ly yl dye EY OES Ls” 5 caperleell Lge li py Le Oy ole pe te Dey Gari, GS aed! J SV of VY ole! ed ob ug ered OF gm Be Sill LAF GB DY le yaa y45 ted oe dyecdl satan se gy peill Hed OUMEy Guill lees iy EULSI E ys ys HNO Ge 3 9Sda e"eb gs aglly Eatly Hf.aks (ar NM ee a gS Ab psig se Glog TU gg 2 23 yo 1986 5 Sahl ola, cage GUT cab Ala 3951 * iy el fot Ge NM see 29S pay ale Ge 5 TU gl go arf called G3 IL ght) BL ye ced 61986 TSI dak caldty dye GUT call SU O52) glo sy Hol 53pode pee dg cla” 95 Eh MI ll 3 lbs Os di Se ON BLAM glace Vi ale ¢ sie oF pet ll pall cp Cbg be JS pl She am ese Geely OB] Us lowe Of agora test! Ob-Leall gS LHL Ugblssy "daly Grell oly 2 Gl EES Lage op pee Lag ted Y eel gat Ulbsl, tS ESM BRA FI ge ASI Up" ta ps Ue HU alee hs AM WY Sp say lbs § GS CTY OB ley OMI Eye aN gles gl jets gh lg Cabsseall LLaall dm piso ky oe toes Bye "gs ss il Silly Gebasll 2g BH IIS AI yee Us! 5 Lie wi ol BH Ube dpa yeti A clades” yond Jp Hy oly We Bob peat le lly «pal Oe le Gin ING sl OM ate ah sty gb ot ge ee enti Dall ie SU ch Lt ys Ha) pase YEG phd DVL 3B Lek ine EE = PO J eat bp Wi cilia 6 wall ed lye ty LO" grslald daly Uvailly Ebi!” by + SyieSl GS Sood ielenly wl UIE GF del ge gael telex Vy JLB Bal yo CLY gp bY 51 AI Sng cabal am ey Ley pgebssly ALE Geis perl! ailay gS Se pb} aS aah V salt cg tell Up ta Leeks iol bot LO" xl th days a be gh dgelti- & 268 2 ey Side "gant ce cleo!” sd eles (1) Michel Meyer: Introduction a Aristote, Rhétorique, op. cit, p. 17. (2) 29 yo ty Side eas 3 wtb sau! 3) 32 yo eens (4) 129 yo ty sSde caglas 23 pl glans! (5) 104 yo 61987 yp a2 yall gla eyed! poll Jd Uda ged teme (6) ANAT ye (9S Og sce clot” yin lee (7) 54assy bere ofl Core sill Jill de WIS Gi gy GLIY of call - @ LS cglSYI OY cenit gf babi Uli] le sold! DVL ard le thaoly tiie at of i> Last 1] Od IS ge uy" ybe IT ast be shall p90 ghee st ab Vy OM plas LU Kk Lace ee “Soaill geal!” of WS Ip 2,20) Yhaill J dy p2illy LY Mgnt GLU dale Ayal ler Of op GlBY py V ede y (Opecall) BH dts} bly sh ab YI ales GLY of Gas ike (Pla SET Ethos GEV, 55 2 Lay Spill cel Logos jaye gl" e OMS Syial Slat! Pathos JL ob seal DAS (Syl oLmnge of Jyill JERZY G5) vey Sy 5A Ke elyl BW oy al prot oe plasdl AST yay eelerd OV uIl GL ay ay ytoll Alksd! 1 OA OY og of Uae Uf" yet ae PI eal olelicy poll a Lypaow oF Le Ctl) 3 Osbde Guill Hay Gol SII Gd Ok Ogg Sle clabing SsLaal Cbal ll knees Gledy yet UUs pled nad og leat LM" aod ye: UU eeogellall sf GLasYly cg Gul OO gilts gt Ogee pol Lf Og elt Gill OY «gs aay By SSS lately Ly paler! Jalna! Ugleees Hla} — & Led gh ee 55 CPW ede boas SM oat yaw flee by sit ely! Qoeatt af a GS gp My ytd ALS Gags OSU 5. el gl Boe" Ul Abs UT GLa! Goss Juul ae igs dled! ELSI Ul cgaslly 31-30 yo ey yScie catbSS 1265 ye Wy ySde "yah ace ches! 337 ye Sle eles 37 9p oS tbs 9 cath ght (4) nti (5) 55tl plas B Qe ot Niele ely ati ole itl LO" fenced dad Hyd oS py dehy Lag Loe te hell CLIY of LS SLL! oie of pecans eae LS al SI poe Lead awe By darlae pole ce Syl ale 1g hy Ley bbs! 53 (LSY! Ge AY OMEN oe Es" JLB. jeeclly all 3 Grell ode ght oe Las uh eg Stalls feel) tally gor gop elecel le pt BSW tem eae Bl ely OLS op he oY ly" S Ua BUS jy Upltcad! SVE ga dee GH geectall ab teats cb Sete Stall of 23) aly "Fable dl yet OL de Lal!" ol Biss eSecelly Gly gested ge Haglens bee! J] Loy algal dey she gical GJ] SD hs de gay cyeds gd 4] Girly adie le gph gle AL 58 eal Ll gt age” gly gaat ade UU Ghaeall 3 SN! bill ye Lily yey ayy pall 2 ULaally 2M Gate (pls! Lill Le of AB baie Glass gar] bln] fy «ferent Slee 3b Wel! GLIY! JLIVL aabes 3} VSS Je WB Lae By ae jplb 050" Ul GB} peal > one OM andy Uplnty OF gelato galt Galella y dag sive 9 JY atey ft: UL 3 aally Viglen yl OValeL ght alan FY Lie Cy alla) (hall ab LS der ages Jacreadl Sle ob GY olay peng] bles Cg 1 268 yo ty 35a yeu | tte cles!” +A 135 Ge elas 93 ill sae! (2) 54 ye awe (3) ty gSde otydoall el ABN JIE gach deoeey (157-156-155-154 tolniall ani (4) 108 Ge 133 ge ysSde celbas ob i wtb yh} (5) ns (6) 56OS 6S ony Gl olalizel chet ah qld Baw Salted sab Le GO ygerul sblee gal JSAM send dom Je ON gett Cyl ao] BIS! Crs!" oA ol aU eld Y! GUL 6 pail saul ke WS oy ob mal be FES qlaall gf Midaud gual! qslis 4 PES oye tts Diss) ole, Le Gl fol La gt geet fs CHaNaSI ge Ll jeeats ge ESI, «JU d yall cLeeall Lay Lay gal Agee tll yu! Clallee ay Hild pS! Usted! Wal eY 526 LS UL adil Vole oy sl pb a sU nF OUI gf & yell olsen! (ew B bepee LS die y (gland gull Cheol! Gilgen Al GA] eI of pet es]y CSN GS gas tne haat Cg dike 3 ay «alll OLgly siglly ple Vly LT GL Be Saal pd Vaeel J Ostare boliall aig Ls eytland pl Of WIS pb gyay BLecly dejeadl eye poly Seg alll Sl La lee PS RAL! gills gent AAS MY Og 0 Kobay od. ASU Engen Lally LIU gel! Gi aly lt Go yeild coe Asi pry Goes ere Ay ined! rll Ey poy ybUII JS, 29539 glad Me pgs tad Jord Lyi! oLIlell oiay Ob abil, DVI tel yd Vikas aly ool ALy 25 cones GU LSI gb ball eg rel AO OA s3t> I garall By sill GB hey! ZY Sele (1) Hades 40 Fy ePloyy Obey bl LL bh - GLY pyldly OLY US oi, o 238 0 11999 JVI deal ola) JL cidydedl cles SS ejell oS de ogee] ghee sale hut (2) 789-788 50 vanii (3) 795 50 tnd (4) 802 J} 789 op lrinall candi (5) 57Ishi fe sill gle pats Y gated pdt ollie Of yaw Y iby pldely (2 bsul say eo glee dae ol elle dthy woes le spolently ylball foley natty I Jerk olds DBL B fled ears Mb dally ile Dy yd Pa lS dy ela le food cael By secilblliall ae Of Dygree gh ol Za BL LY ged Ged Lb de Lai (oy jas elas] le Yds te ten ye co gland Uabrece sf pllanll id Late sf cgateat cee Ba sf Yoeel 6g AU Jad) OUT ye Gots of dey pido Ju adh or nay tad pe OSS SIKH Ys ee UII ode Yo (I) shoot jew sdb pd gpa ASI J Ag BOK Migs pa Sil Leoeers Me gaily Le Uy Ub! be le ob By hw ol ops BH I LS Lal oo Wale Llacal a6 Gilly Paralogisme bila! clrodl UY goo aad We pe tale goed Gall cleus a5 Ke plas a gta AVY ally a] ell pt ts Les LOY fare OL VI 42 fees Lyles Un appat Lea" ue WU chia! (3 Cbu ol pli! dis, oll, als Ofy cogany sles clr 4] Ogee GLE Gued Ly plSeall Bee ged OB pie et Lele sla 5 poll Kal OS Lily DSN 562 ASU SEY fod fos Min 55 09 p-gree DIE ge on Ma yaclly Lanes!" oe Clee abu) go CIS she TE OF das! be 826 J} B03 gy brine LIU oll ey Scie eget Glare lh shunt (1) 197 0 63 Se ody doull ey aN Ide yack tame (2) PC OL pal yee glredl AB 3 ee Ebel! ILI" + @) 404 Go Sie. 410 Gyo nd (4) 69S us prgll call OA ogd> I gat EWS HEY Gao WM YVidle yl le 6) 225 ye 58aes zal elis Ul ac lly io lLull oll caljill 59dail Lie toll idell [gall Lagsiig Leo tall Halal sic claall sa Bela] -1 has! UI pled pnreibsl syall ee Gg gl Comrade JELE pd weg yte eT Wane Y Sled OF LS cay pl BY! JSF beled! o Bee GSA OL se garclly bd OSs lpr GUS ale J Hej yall walete ool Gt PSY WH Cols ge ASI OL Yeas La all BI OF to oye 250! sLitel (5 el Ad OF By AUSS B gle ol oully Elly ty pall Bh UF LL hata Koy dane de gill botedl We oe obs Lbs phe Ga grdall Gilead! el 4S PlSYI Ler, abel pLasaly Ce ee EI GUI oT pad Hes B GB JS bse UNS sili cee Brel in Of 4 LIV pre tpad Oy gs cll! edolealy gy bball PID peel spl abe JS 69 GH stad ely le dS gi! cles le oT UW OLY OLS gels ol th ll Leste gta dad] Dna ge Ande a la V egmerlenadl ge SSLaSI ode ciel] GULL BI Ley A] obese PMS, Lael Lath, aglyy ceo ba "Las Ltiey Sle J Le jke"y OL, asa" Bil Wat pS laos "JUAN de sling foul! Lil de cbse WI by Opp natal sku’, 661.9) C9 yo eel gla Wyybe dames PMI Le Opty GT tgeally Ob eb! (1) 8 Ge IM ejal 112 Ge tends 2) 91 ye nds 3) wld yo and (4) 61(Natl de gla!” as ail) he Loli Gis ly paleally Ji SY! adh SY of (G94 Dyke PIN toy phe GB Ths! gle JEAY Lely ue WIS 094 CAMs woleh oll ae byebe gb belo BL...) Bote! Cole bs" ale egal ES ope ope 3] MEU 53 Oo DT LS ttl gd pay a wala y Wi sh AST Lele eral eatly Obed GES (5 oo y 31 gl Ona Lola, GLA alles die by Gar” Ghd! af pyle YL sll coy Oly alas Jyley BIN Tyee Ge Le bedl Golly of Lah ols WU BW oles age Jrorsll opr y wheel go STI debe! Hol seed Melly OLY IS op pad gd Usls b ables tole ee ee 4b 2g de Y dyill ete de JM Ub IE ge Lebel pgp te G Ghee SVL BU bys leyeey He 5S 5 IIE oe oF sill 3B LY, pBY! sib bo Jl oll Lobal eel / dleally plisll ig pare Balall dooyoo algiyl -2 ALT AM olinantly Syrull JS ells Gly OLY petll ab i 3 thay gral PLE WU EES Ht JS) ale pal OLS!" sabe Jy ey WIS Syraree gle pages iim cll pall pais go pperll O99 Glee Sore GALI, VI le OY ft O15 ae gl gay bed LS als OF Comedy ples CAL ld (LY y ped po Lei] Ly Jota! Ly 5) Vayolary pnaliy Gal ce RENN SH yb fp Lye qgyall ol 62 yo 4f1962 — 61381 WU ded DL JW dader ch pall slew 2: GAS Gye) yori Ol I ey shdy el wo pl te BI Se 12 re ae @) +305 ye 61994 SII tLe epi gs age GW TIS Gly yt us (4) 62OM and gad U3 gb Obl yo HUG gal ay oS Coe Wl Wy cS liebe Fb Of Ge pall Le yg earnl de og gh ral Lig PLB YE OM ceti]y aol tt Lil" PLY! SAN hee ce Seid LLel gil dab gM sleely ge oe 2 VB ty bey Cady Gy EW GL pe pak Gill Jal Of Si gil nals O'all Sho Ly lpall” 0595 ceil ge Whe GES La] ey ee fod obey Lal sh GAs Lelistl ge GLY! elas pe Ye AS Les Of Qereally AISA ne plead LL II Bib y D913 ISH ed ces -creedly pal JY Lgl OL Goda or Sal eae LAE Wl gsi) Gls slg es bs Lib Sy Manabe obseY 4l] ab pS pW! by Ye Lobel chu] af LYE pies cereals BU ay Ue byt) Ul aS J ob pall PI! HS § pall Lacks cdg ce Gp Layee pill ode IIS Gee OS etl GUBII § ISS! bLid Sl ee oe bold tk Il Ba ESL LE bl is plbl as ISS WB cl Sal ol gi] le Bay pbh oN oy) LB Spall Gils, jad Gb Og tle Henkel! Of Koy tll CEA OLS gb ge UU bey LU ot oye HS GorLe bey ie YI Ye lpg LAU le WLU Sale Dy deed ee pL Yl ge rtd gh pts ate bee hele gai WY gall Eyl pels was OLS BAL oye PAK Lnlead by pb le (LBM Glee any ab ares 276 50 SSM ojxall Sd oy Aly Dh kota (1) Bi ll pli BAH Ulos Lele egy pall Jas dy 2) og all Yaad as ag los Ne das (2) 225 yo 61993 US taal ola — Oye eg all sll 5S pall i 1136 Ge IV ejadl She eg 1200 0 65d eng ZI 63SW shetty Ogatsly pailly Alay GAWly dereclly debe gy oh agai BAS s BLY de Ge pally Hobs Vicar die bed pple 5 AW 155 pol TAB gl 3] (LY ty ae gaty idl ol HLaBY le deg cals BY YY QL oe Wg dbl de VI sta" ob Coke telrdB US i 52 YO" Go I Goes OM daoh WS gol DLL IIS Ly cogil PY! hey sents Balall 469, (A plily) dibs -3 creetlly Ohad US Hal pel oles Of! 1g peal Lares y SII Sp CSM ME 4 Qo Dyber OUSUI Mie ot op25 JS GAS doled Lasley pA OUaL» J) HeLa a) ab" saat og gall OUbasall Le jS spetenell BL Su bey DLL G5 95 J yas ge Lag Ley gh VI CAlge Byaslly SeSl pall BAW ler" yb glVy BAI by, WY AelBLy ale pp glilly (gerne le SEU Uy yas LENG OL ll ales Jf ead shee sf pila a> Yo yd yydee QL Jy all Of gh de CF te etl Gl a ge eGpesll plisy Meee ead J Le Dye ll oe Ka By cogil 4 ded iy cy oe [pall he] Ol ee ale lay &.. lal 1, gs thoi ts 2 eal 8 by 2h O83 DVI yds J Whailly deodl clad A GB [ey] ae t55" ONE pal aS] esislly cp gil ce Uyially fesl ad dtc Jil Yann (I LelSYI Gal BY og pall teres 5 Sl Gas wy stall phy Gebvailly GLE Jory Gylall Dlazal" (3 Bebe 3 pai ae AAS G0 VI ejaall She — 200 Ye e356. ZAM Kill tayere ole (2) ATL ye IgM ejall Se ccelly Old sdamLedt (3) AND Ge ta sSde BIAS Gell PGP plaadly glbsd plist” (4) 88 Go ISM oe jaull Ss cally a (6) +7 ge IM ojaull Sd caclly Oty! tdemlell (6) 64AT gy Mol Joy pally ses, DLV esd elas Goby DN Gi Sy Casdly gill ge ole ple pe GULLS La ay DY op S5y CLAM Lonely GUY Slope yd p35 rey Gael Fe jhadly i BisSy Clee Vl ples jay Y GiS » Hw sly Levy Himba) ae ald Lad Lee oy oer Jolt “URS! Jai” gl ode JY gh) Reins (Sl Upc p35 SLs UW ne el Of BL" Bb BWV gee yl i sled WE spay tgretnell le creed ye JEL A iy pgiletel dep 3 42) OLS te Dy it! ON OM USS fuad Gisf BCS HS GES le Rood dhe pL ELEY (A Ua 929 pli LL} 4 LS toads Obed g By Aa Heal Cole pees ge pe WSS y ol glee oe 355% Ob Gp od Gadlly" we Leb ayy Shas lpall le Gp til a Lally Gabdl Giles gs 0,5 ob eas GS LOM Maal oye ples JS) Gore ey Sul Sil ye Qe dna! (32t sle hele JS ob LIV ths plintl ilels 0555 cee ll Le By hala ye Lee geclly dled FOI dy “Ola” ) “Lael” "Bs "DLout"y "plist y “aad yall” Yoey cb til Wa cde ots 7 eat pol ge eo" Po yene Golem ame opty “Laless!"y “USLAI"; "Hebel!" 355 ye oe Mee deal ple sgh pS [Bobi] 9 55 (3 Hee JS hy alery yl Leth Bebell te plisll Sy Uae Hall" 53909 2 I pe PI slsely ables slick ¢ Sour AKoI dl ples a5 op GU GL sliely Ws 61999 39 pp = Lag II 6G A La st clptalinly Yl yel dy pall Bgl (D BL ge 9M ejay ySia eel OL ce @) 1136 ye ends (3) 209 0 ey Sd PII Si aye Gale (4) 65HS (ASA poly Ob "Led Lily" ais bball po prated nee WSs sl ler ys OS pl BY Gs V yal ole WI pg poy ecb Bhyally WSS Olas NE gabled OLS [gnats aI Leb OL bul Ss lib oye ply: Ot pKa gle Gor gy WH ergs PAY ols (BULL 538 655 JS pled] le DAM js OY gratin Upaly libs JO" fares ot Me Baill AKA 05d gle iT cde pede frosty oat De PIS ST ais go lie GUS ge Ue JS y (Lads Lb WSL Le gretnall shuily GLUES ji le gla hal potty gles! ONSYest 5 Raed) (ISeall jLarrnl d3 dkay bud gp abby olbsdl doled Doe Jo EE Og SY edd JME a by oily goal eqydlcadl GUY colts FV Ne QodEY gaball a Cbueall dled ale poll oie be bbs aoe of bi Ly J WW gigs 2 al JR4 Bole oy Ady DSA chee Le ivan Bb Ly pe HOULS gd Leda Uglied Jy Leal ll ges Qld aah dee bly [1 doll be bled!" 4 Glad tle tomes shes est dl) Abs Bo bah, os By Jol Lee Qs ye tl OMS ety caball oF GA! Lad am glial le Ga gd eplill dele 3 Jil Leal eo pate Ul sles oly Gab JS] Sy pey Jp dae ope frail pre iat! wlio ISI) GUE BAN fp cole bd! JS i Milles BAS ory welgd yo UL obras jlew Dll ye pases dale Aa yey ot Ory Js cess ce le YI [ans aai]" plicdl (3 pl JY! We lode Loledl dpe WAS y Gyslruatly Uslrall pi fy DyLtall eles rat alles te, 2138 Ge JV ejadl yySbe cgeclly LI emLed (1) 25 0 395d sg pall faall Ley (2) pall fia! AB ig ple tile dares (2) 66lin By Wher bas 53 yy tially Bp Halls Spill Lee pl O"esalecdly GLI te Uyily dase! Jory fowl (US oly sity OF nat bial ilar Gebs OL wey lg hale (SI 03 yliy PIT oLasl 555 Ob Aad ole ole od se Bape The ge Mails Laill lsat" Oye) HS OyL5 LSU YJ CUS US LS Estee pall FD GL I le DEY jyley cb y pS Mee 033 ESD ty ye lic) Sliall Zillee de Leola! cl} of ava Se vag tbel oars elie nds ot edly eis GL Ke epliall dela Al DVL) pled We 55 Al of tee lary LS cig oe der yll shy lbs! BHA ye Bole ou WU ZelSY GLE pate SI Jp tl J Lads desl pV Lele le idly Oy dy OF Ser Qadly Ab lb" kota 29! Gl el La tbs dais ga bb eld all Ga SL AI gg Ube st -©"bragmatique du discours 6 0 LI egal Ss CGelly Ole 212 yo 95d 6 BIS SEEM so yao alee (2) 301-300 Gyo 655d 6 BI KEE co yas gale 3) 67Siti 20 oll Ayal yliyg ung y dloul Gaby Cel aie glaall Uga Sela} -1 Ga al] Nabely Leela aod Gill Stl GW ope tae Baba ganadl US ty on poll OF Boy I TO" sats Bie Al ibd! olla qui pod ot (Sa Cy Lal pes gd pol and ley beled fT cchsuly dently Lat Ve O-Ke Lele WIL age Ca Sey lara AI Lola oda cutesel By. polStaly Pikes) yle ygSll OU ye Glindh cmey Of dep winrar 3 ET Ep0 OB ral Old!" 3 ey pte gine y, Lal all oda wale iy gle CAbe Vy Ol.JI dg ch ai Obl! -2 BLY y Leal!" Gyo ell Laat 3 Obed oye y o> JB Leto ols 13} LEY by" ty Lad Lolee any ool Ob OLS, bly Lady las] are Calall GB rare GLI OLS CYL ae OL" genes "Lele Uptly “sgh Oly" eeeny "OL UL Obl eatee YI Oly!” Gangs € Sal OM SEL ob" 21 ge Sd dlptalialy pel tall BUI a a gSAN pad gel GIN OD LE GI) WV AIL lw yl Gad dheyl ele @) 61997 JsNI Reba e ASI > eaglly glo dads pe My AU ULSI jlo ep jbl deal 305 ye 1g pall dares 33 Ge 95d tog pall Jal Ly 2) og pall fal as Hg yield Ye tome 3) 2213 yo cy sSula dlgibalinaly Upely Gy a BASI £76 go IM ejall cggeatlly GLI sdimled (4) EK Spb dane im 9 KSA Sosy Slt Whell ogey gb Dezdl ay ox dl (5) 156 Gyo 1969 5 ala! walt 68daldes HLtYly OLS JL led oly ya Cory oy! Le gle YI Oley Sod oS) Ube gad Lt" of Ws LY! Shal Gle Leth, Gall OB Ry eh ms el ly bl le OO" sol ad slew jen Obs a] Ue SB bY / pid UT ill aga gh pod Ste pall weds otal Ving My Sill Jee] te lal gb rary" ole VI aly LI heal ps5 Oba pli aI Ling Obs & artes Ge opal BH Eyl LEW BUI Yosby Maly gad LAS Ul ByU ote gay WES O15 eT ay onl janet 48 sla! OL, LT qo Y alb oly cline BL wl Stay Jill oly GAT Ley LUI OL, wzSdly SIV By LAL aN regs bb Oley GS I! Ying ON gt cal” cel 3] OSI oly te Quay Gal Gy dsl, Ve any oy! ine by CSL y alt andi pas fp tals le oie pari Sy bet CSS abel Leet Nee od JS od greateall sleel bd vege GIS (Ko CSISs Lololl] sie Gils, bd Ag Gl Olas ely! all -3 Of Shs I ood gry CLM, DV J) ola dl 3 ob Rinaldo Kary apgladl oles derbedl tery ols WHS 3 gle cary EE ALS ogee y Ob peel ge pratt Obed ge Gay oy! go> po Lets} Gb oe cdalitas a yr NM OSs HUE YbLo Shy Lal Led! ye Cee peed gb ISB ileal ole Os he G GLEW Gl plly Jaa! A ghas Way O sylind VOLT, BLL pape Gl] 4 plan Iabicel 65 0 cents (1) 156 ye 13 95d ld opry J Oba dt ory gy: GL-| (2) 186 G2 4s (3) 1254 yo ttendi (4) 69scadhe U3 Loy lily Jaal gar feats ry Gil OS pS onal Mee BA OLSY Slee] ge grb ONG 08 ge Mey fill Ie LA! pen, WH die Joo Osh dle Vy «fall Joo HLM, LAY 3 dial! pty Mikey OOH hey DISA" Cay gil te OLS) faa! ob g zk! waa gl fu VY] ps Y tere (seb Gay ol te Obl Ls of cabeey ee ge pert Beall DLE VG Gay pl ste Oleh phe OLB oye LBS je BIW TG pall Seal ode tly HLS Jol, sel Old oy eb GF Ghtall J red jh yaa y Lad Ee beodl RADI dN] ple Stony topredall Ghil p59 egapall pe Glad J] sage rai SUT By pLal gh ey te Bay ool al se Gil GSA ell ge CHW y tall Qo Bybee Lele Lyle oh] Ly ered Al OSS poi IS 36 VW ball cre dls” dpe Lill OL BS OI Layy am OLY US pute Lom cgoll als 1 Las Ub bell lpi] ge are Le E58] de ST SM gpaatie Nad gpl SANG LAMY gis ge VW ld Go V6) 10g) ad Ghtall Gla es el be ely Lat o OL sR Ly G..) Gb OP" bua AS Cary gl Gaal ide Laity Us Gall Le gs est nd Ba A yay gles cee LAY (La) PY! Bk 3 EZ I DST pelt LHL shyt ke debe Obl 3b Gab gh dani SUEY gay oY as p ylz be le pte JS ay og! By 4B AUS OM igpbged) Sp!" 959 dea be gh gst J] oleate o» Ve E899 ela ogrlrodl adh gly Coty gl Of ALI Gre ey 34 go She tgipll Jaa 2) pall Jaa ae rg pled tle dow (1) 68 Go Ske dN agey BOW SI Ay gy Glue] 2) Oswald Ducrot: les échelles argumentatives, op. cit, : ky (3) 70sip «ple Lite jeans, OT Sal" gh GIL LS lye 3 YI dle JYSeoNI ye engl git lll" EB ye Le ts! ade Jaen oF} clea pe bly GAS YOY abe pie I, OD eo Gy pas BAT eles £5! BW GLESI fy "|S" oP dade DYE SLE, gle aly od bl ee by Gila LS dated! elas Y OLY baka Al ollie Wy LSI OB wey ol opt diy pel Ol Min ang opt jay yi sTyLe cle Lace! Yee ll OM pe eo ad Sats OLIN! OY bs Pl SLEW Role oy Ob ti OULU ial, pal ip of palby OT glass sly VIS Yd gebbeall gy peli aot 5) aad dled Jay Gee VY) Bos Vy FIL Be 8 VY] egw Y glsyl Bu de ab SU pe Ab OH pg Ebb OL es go UDlany cb pay Lay tiny Le cole ob] Lalas 0 pb olf ag pl&e JSS" role JI Lee gall Ss ot ges 8 GLI Shy OG tery alalizel 5 joa, ob My eS eo felsdly bE Lil tye b Gls als ob 2 BISA Sty eh > Le 59 Llp Gael J pl 5 Of al foe Lael Lge yall Lge gol URS ole I te obs I Ly gate cgpSyslee Gti: Lagat Qallly “Late ol" deal SerSI By ll Jer By gab! ye ogre Wp tte pS dash SISSY AY sla oF GEL dley, LS c telisl dale Je Jad Later Michel Meyer: Introduction & Aristote, Rhétorique, op. cit, :,34 (1) 68 Ge She tN ogry gf Ole ay oy: GL] 2) 5B yo hn (3) 37 (ey 5e ASI ple dtndy pdt Ipol gle SNe ab (4) Bhinee belo) Ure gad Gal glee os goa nttly clea!” gala Sot 6) TOT yo 41992 wlll saath GELS dual 71UG] ag, ted dys” Lgl Ualeally Jad) Gas 3 yk devel sleely thie Ob ySag Hb dado LTO" Salecall stated 43 Hl Leb Lol eb GI bey cateall Gels BL Yall abe oe ty ol a OM" aa pall pad (ASS WS ote y PITIL SLI Ul alan oly past! Menace DLS slidey AAS jldde Strall A ol ALT OB elteally de le Jers Lay! HBr, CAIs 1 stall 5 lye yd ge JS ty Gill lgeall igs Lely ALL] Ke Lat! Taig 4b CI SN cle Go.) aetallly OMS Clee Vy ayy J clow Mame le nol ce ft Y Let] ry ol oe GH OL pg GLI Lis Gy Obed Lin Bae OSS cdg AB yp ley Glee gp cay pally Gab! obesiall Y UBY cee he Bedly gril le V Gated Gb" ge Ui pao ly WY) Scum Bly seust sara) Ubu! cing pall OL tall op "gba SI Gi gels LEM ge ry ol by egal ol] IM Oba SB sgapall Glial begs ge he! Wie G2! Glee stow LS wily bye yale Dltge pis ald glans] ade LS Gary gpl lagles clout aye dlliy OAM WSs NF pled pais yay shut ol" deel JL ey Gp! 8 GB prally dpi Selo! Lanbdl p+ yt Lis 3} bey GLa Gandy Sul gb Cod! ate Lary Lele oll 3 Gebel PAY Dany sb oily SU By I ain Vl oy pb BN UNS" 23 3 yh Gal CLS 3 Le stall 2 cel il 176. 2 6) 5d Whedl agry B Oa ay g: Dee] (D 248 42 enki (2) 186 2 tend (3) 187-86 yo dns (4) 187 yo en (5) Michel Meyer: Introduction & Aristote, Rhétorique, op. cit, p. 15. (6) 72Ode andl ae LDS or ge be GIN gu odes oda tO 1] OF ome Y IU grated poll gle play Vorb pit Say oly Yad gotlland yl alice!” to dabdly Gli by aly Whe J ede LOMB oye ogi did ladies 53 DIA LY! gle ay gl Gee Wt GLI gy (SYN Ny GB Gt ANE ge any te dey Y Wy aL! ULaill ores B deh tcl! ai OUT oy UT dae GSI Ly cel Gilly Fle] ps5 JS cceoly 43 ole! Fy Gl GW all oo ool ed pbs Of” Al Oba Great ab Ubi alll ge ge oT las OS OB 445 Gol OM ge Ugel ay coat oe bi, Yd BN ony ool Eat) GetSY Ll Ue Ct Ls Gabs gl Baal Sears op Sebel Hall a dred Ob 202 gla zl slacel bts GLEsI" yf as tall Gye” oy "all" gh "Cas" (bole SUI glial Sled 3 Lily SV clits Grad!) bd 2,5 at 52 Y vere Oke shy gens OT ane Gey law caer gs 87 ye 3 9Sde DI opr y GD ey ge Gee] (I) 88 2 andi (2) 89 2 wt (3) 73full 10 oll JMectualll ae Wig XSL ell cghlSudl ale glaall Usa Se lcal -1 (BS oF Si Gere rll dey Eyal BAW hey SII! dle does 5 95 Jy WH, ira Qarcll ab OI ter ne Yell OMS Bb yg Ebay BLT LAL WW Gad ya pe ghul chia” Of g ples! Ciel ode Lptedly Ud} SL oe Lyall FT ep ps dey Min BBL got: Ist 5 opens gill ddl Cole DI 3 Le aes fee gal OL! of dy all Led! Ld J al CISL" St of ySe Y CaAU Raaliall Leo ole AY OMS Sy dg SII wal wali Ay all BI GG Be de Gil perl Cell ed Bopp ty Last oJ! pets ell pee Gil Carel pet Gs LS” Ol sel 3B dels PES Bad (BIEL 059 King ppl Opens pplard SIRS OLS A AUy aS y= Oy z5ts GU Cail ogee go> ab AS phy 1 SII came GIN jad Gib dT OF yay Y OUS derlys Of LS OG prose Fee WY Gledhill Obed! Be YS Geng Mids Ubi Shel gm LO" Shall Ba pana” dye BAY bed ys clad oe AB BLL Got | > ash Lj i (gSiSuall ABD) (gb SYsinw) -2 del 3 Meg pte oe Wate pb geet 5 CLIN LE CIS 13] 90 G0 She yall Jas ey (2) yall Jat Led ule dame (1) 251-250 yo cy Sd 6. gall Ob BL’ gsr (2) +254 ye sents (3) 497 drial J] ATT torial oye 5 She clglalicaly UP pol iy ll EAI eg peal tomer (4) 74elS] CEL Gil Gay or SIRS) ae Ghisll BAI! i, of Ghul aalaily cqarmely plitl, aslazaly clytotes EAU oy pai ae avai: Lb Ad, Ok 3 ps sly SYR pe gh cose olall Min gills ool phe SII 6 ENN eee ple 4b i pall le plas Ul asles platy cdl soul ples aalesy GF pall glesll ple plas Lely cllly plead ple sb pro! ple olor Ul, Gle2vI tools BH OSI OS, Why SYA, dod! ple 56 Std Spall ple 3 INN gill - eel ple 1M el - Prledly sleatl ele J A eal = egale LELD GU pbb, oj} 3} SII yt deeb os Bly AR Age gs (SYM soall) Gheally dee ge gull ee Clally Jlasll Ae Ake UB gh ol "pull ila" U pie SIS 4B tater FO Ley Nn BES ody ll AU Ueto Uilae Rt) (gill alles pull) 5] «gle zal all polars cand Wlnaily Gli Lia latte; Lal YY] Gad “PIS pli” I OME Lol pl dele Bu och Ralisll A WLAN" est af BW De le S Fi ped Sebel OL wl of dS ary JSS tp brodl aly Sy Yelp Jp > 959 UG SL Jody pool AS le Vis bed ye gle BVM sel cll de SII pas «pitt Lh gs SVs Vy ould gebey ilaal ple plas OW Ly" pH gladly OI CSI AIS Mob MI" Whe ge Gael Of OLY, eel ye by J cee See tll Et de dy SY (lbs le ols! EO ely 197 Chena 25H 19 69595 prot Mle Gey tal ym Sy dhs ep gla cede | SIRI (1) 8-7 (yo «9 1987 — 91407 StI taal! A850 19S de dlgilalacaly IW pol dy EA gad dene (2) 6 2 354s op shall cleie | SIE G3) 75LVYoeuly Dyas EAI fare Les eal plas le Lange OL! SIE oe ileally Ob geley goely Ghtall ga 03] Gb! 13h Ren yale lilin, os all LS! Madd 5 Stall eal Yl" po BIW! Osadoee Vee Node of bp GE B gill GL bad I fst as Y OT pele Saces" WS ob SIS Ike SVE y fol slacel, VY] pated Tats dgler gy daly er PAS! Ollie sho J] Ky SIV ple Las Yaclst Spang JVM PAT OSL Qo OF Cale gogo 3 MW OlSy glel ple ole pj ely) (A pllall p53 -3 28) BPAY edly HLol pl ebgl Ue Sora! SIS HO} coke pay Cee tigleally Obed phe lus Lagsbery cqarmelly pliall de B dyad LJliy plist Lab ede fo Liles 35% Y pS Of chatall ell Fale lal SII oi) iy Lod! ated colts eV sd ge ee LEMS aealee ops bee (SLs pL JS) LY Reg pling SAI ple aly Stall plind aisle PASH Glebe Of de jal he +Lgll pling (...) pall plia gale Call pling dy jal plan gral Aplin BH pole Sis GN sdad Like OGY oe ek ple ply aol Lolly aba OGL. e tals "Sed ariel pS! dele” Gaull Regal SES gy GU sel fe ges Giga gle plist! pais oS ESS JS" OB "plas ASI ad] gee do JS" OF LSS Lape Ls Lilie Wigs Lan, eter pty lbsly lbs pig Jedi OM" Lae Lgea le we ABD yo ty Se oendag yall BA ig pal aoe (1) 432 yo 6 95de opglal chain 2, SIRI (2) 168 yo 695s op glall che 2 SIIB) Anti (4) stents (5) 76Bye) ASL YB Us) og¢r ge Ley SIE OJS Y aol VI Pda Y ceo (petal place Solin! SIS ge Ook Y pod og tlle oe Cam bla Ue gly Le sa YY pS Ua DAL pan re PIS toe A] Oe ala PLS Coe PIS ay gl racilly ti ci gllan olecnl le pyle lb ISy tet trl oe wl Vdee PASM gd plead ial ISB" cps cqully trated ial! Lie = bul 638i] BB ot 3 al] tena Sl OSB oded OS aT si Be O55 penal Sele ds OWS jai, Ybbe Lble aS a ee gail ge pe" Nk GLEN! Sul Ob Wise, dere Gl pst Oyate gb 2a tay SL bbe Sard ollll sul Li 099 ote Lb poe ld) Sb oJ) [4 sl ead!) Lew 131," J ye cad] Altaf, dad bya mrad pol dbyy ye ddI ge ge ce yg) OLY GIS SSI LF .O"L Lb st Ep Me pany deal 95 ASI SH oe ASL BLEU 0 AK] oy SF cle Uebey Sie Cb Les oad A} a5 SDE Led (SL I] [SS Maal] Lalit 1)" 1 SKN Jy SEY eal tle ne SE Cer Ad aS Co el HE QR OMSL SSN ope Ell Ma gay (..) alized J “aga” LI a PIS aly (NKaSl OL NI Cine Gey ates eebladl LF lees pny LSI Test gael" of beg of pull pati, LbLS Ib] CUI 0% bi las dues Ae" Tio) 3 Oar OH Gade gd gd Lagi: eel st _YU ce bb tae YE Ollie fb Oey JE LS, OL fee +180 0 chads (2) 1170 Ge ents (3) ATL go (3354s ep shall clei 6 SIE (4) +320-318 0 cans (5) 77“eas "olds “abt, “epasll”y "OSM" fees al Jew de OO gly Tiny EAM day JB SIL OS cgatnally plicll, placa Yl JAE or opal de pi By Lelia oy Sst Gpatly cdl yeMy plist! sAelS] By Le Ce Grail Jylasl Fatal 6) guall Asysiy) Aaya! -4 dete SF ede opr cle pps Y SIS ce git! pall Of Leal Le! ance ye pla Lee SVseal opagr Ot Ju eel eV! J] eel ge DUM le py WY tee p pall Lites saa = VY> MoV bee ol WYo J Ere gt DV ge gh eal em lt Ree eter OF pS asl! ye US Aall olny dejne Uo ASW, Lala Ba Hged pa 5he dL (SY or SUB ters SY I pa Jl! ab yally CE Lee) Syd LS ASW II py toll op” 43 ULE OS jlo LS cpa jbedl GM pSU! gps Ue fate ULE ASW Aged Uc yay a5 WB caleell Sb ype g2 Gill Eabdl Jyh tally oleall Job OG Jp ge Oma 3} Hyg UD 255) Yd erad sf ayb abet Jar Gi] her WH pb Oks ge pe Ley op Dy SVM le alt ogy 03] SKI SIRI ie glee Obed Ge 3] eld Lindl they) ysdly eyes Bhi (pad pKa taeda dant pins Lee “Soplaall oar” Glas RAS" Byary gh geod ly Sdwh eg OLE ge bs 2 ALD TLL gf deptall oly OU ge oo) Bye CO" JS obs Sf LS BT yd leo L Y] SIRS Gam 4% Y OL IE All oe si 1320-319 yo end (1) 1330 yo edi (2) 331 Ge hens (3) ABS 0 05d eg ghd) cle 1 SIRI 4) 78eo] Wy oo gd ube gl OASYS Wy Jue gb Led pple eagt et!" ya Lol 65 oT sy Ed Qed Copy Late) HO Cg 13] Him . él eS BL fo gl ly abl oy I Wy fro 3 ABlal Bpodl pj 3 CAD taal ob I ES ON Oe OF ne Lt CoS COL SI par O98) UE WE oral 13) fo gf thus ce Glad OW Gail I WE Wo sy teacly lhe oe Goat og placd S98 Oe 55 Ol bs (Lal plod! 9) Gola yon Blpsdy Lat) CB pA Le Le cay 13] HLS Yo gl tad Bu baad pl jl} pb Ke GL’ plod! (3) Ob sf GrLay OD 533) CU yl OMe CLI Mid Bed ep glen Jay Gil Mandl ine od ty SIL Eyal Nb SII far a ASV ely eles Vu OL de oF GE by JY Coble ole DSA TLS LS jo low VE poled! dp lesd) Cola ale 35 pu ales OF yet Bh ary jul Gey LW eae J dL Se ab ead O" deli Gall ye erleny abe Js GL Jil” OM gly ry GV rbedl LY eles jel al Cadaale Kelis BY Oe Neral AKA yay SII Sb 1H Lol eats OT base OS JS WY ZeLSY! Leb Less JIN le 6p 5 sesbl panel dee I Grd Ye oper ote Stall I tll SIS! nad Ue] Laas Le LAS the pates opr sy Lal" iy pie gl dpe OMe SW SI a ab Le 8 PAS ges bell plod] gp Joeed SILI OL ULI Lie + po ley 505-504 jo nis (1) Chaim Pereleman: l'empire rhétorique et argumentation, librairie philosophique : jk, (2) J.Vrin 1977. 310 Ge Se ell 2,5 sf Ojeally GLU cdl Jape ab (3) 1313 M304 ys laivall andi (4) ADB ye 35d op shall chide 1 SKN (5) 79aU 55 pl Bye LSS Y plead gg Used Ob OL pels ileal sledl pa ed cy cane lie J prolly, LU Ble tare He pS cred pa lye He pa” Jy OY chibes ba od gill ae be Oa ayy aL J Be Vs eer Al de JhyeVI AATB ye 695d egal fall dey 2) gpl faa i reg plot tle teow (1) 80ENE ais lis. ic Lh Cyrall ysl Glut 4 81idalll 0 sol elaalll dehy siLasily ylolss lal yal gales ¢.5 pduall Uga Se lial -1 SUSE 5 fla cye Laat SLAY ge Uy 8 Cie uF ELIYA CUS 13] Cee gD ee a y4lid Sarl ude EAN old SI Ege I Ob ig nell Gy las lel py 6 iy .L. Olbrechts Tyteca X55 «Ch. Perelman otal J Ces) deadly gy pall Godl B rdl bls 3 gual Oslll By pSoy Se ge pecedll Soo ye HLy LEW dye 5, Kall GLALe at YI Gall salgall cl Valeurs poly lob I} eat Coedll 55 yall AsLadly Dd) i polrall bbl eal jas LEY Lab gs Gl C9 teh! JVs SIS SL aolacal tj UY LEY ye dy geelly SS al alll le JURE Ly ele nil ple ley Lg) gil Ss Ghia debe le Del pp Siew celled obaSl plasty GLSY! OUD! seal Gt yond Elrod! Aly Go pail Lelyo le GB Sally gy pall cghesd ope LT aig Gadd J line 79 1958 Be Votre J Grae Wy all Gaul sLealI lbe yasy Gast Sa spay Olly Qrod SKI JS) forall ied! prnall” Fle Jelye ool] CSM EL elod of Ola Gy 4+ GeorgesVignaux 3 WW ed A Relerll LNG Salt gored yay attl o tly obs I ays als ce BUY ode Ag Lal Gad JE G2 peel Gt OL gi OL es fr Lae ee yates 2 tl bl ‘Ch. Perelman et L. Olbrechts Tyteca: la nouvelle rhétorique-traité de Vargumentation-T1, (1) Paris, PU.F, 1958. Georges Vignaux: L'argumentation du discours 4 la pensée, Paris, Hatier 1999, p. 7. (2) 83Gly GE) I] Obagi GU! J all SIL, heal 2 AAS” OLS joy Dd clad od fore IS Lol AL! oda OS gally all Ulptey Spi Aste OB eall gf Up tall” ye UES J] 1934 Law be herded Sal baad Ol ger JE hell B rae 4 Of eld or Way BB Sans on Bebo pl id Gl ope Joey Veet Sly dag gl bey OAM OLbe lS 45, oA! Jl sy SLAY! Gee Debye 4B ly dod Uyrrtey LB Ribera sd! bbl dell) derteall atall tas" ga Naadge quel be OF Obed jad Ly ad) da Ltt Ay kIE A oblLsd Vy tiles Oyo Ade HG LB pakill Lie Gey] Eble Laslett Jel A eetike ST eget ALG Bs 82 Lge linha} ipbe isl 359 des" gl ele faall Gaal, Lie Obl 2 OS Ad OM gKod Mase! 3 Oy dele! ole oly LB wb Y clovall times oy 4b O} DUM G3 dine y Leen Os ell Oil joa Aa 23 xe Oller) cls cil BW paced Balas Lepeye Leyte Sylaeall forr bow Muley Be cp dll Obes AY Ql dy OLE Je SUL Leb! day shiy Whe ye dbs Glo Al Cay! OLS eg bograll 3 Gitrae ester gil ELIMI TE sod Gyill ole! Of 05 Ce debell ge pelea! Sill 8 apne Gapall Geel! G3b oe Gime Ue ESS at AUS 35h, LF OSL ody QOH yo oes all Ula Ibid, p. 7. (1) Ch. Perelman et L. Olbrechts Tyteca: la nouvelle rhétorique-traité de 'argumentation, (2) op. cit, p. 8. Ch. Perelman: Justice et raison, Presses Universitaires de Bruxelles, 1963, p. 15. (3) Ch. Perelman et L. Olbrechts Tyteca: traité de 'argumentation, op. cit, p. 6. (4) Ibid, p. 1. (5) Ibid, p. 3. ©991958 Ls s3b Yad RS ab pT Gye Ct ge esd tole ogg ole deny clr Cpt ser ol oral gf Oped] gir COL LO" Gata Coy Uyler” aio yy Hye Lie J) bi 3, qlee place! om bel ja Er rte G Gbrodll Aki p ghty gM EH J do yl Of gers Hhadly sypnall Gate! ahasy 5 Sleall Layton lle Ley OF AY gt SH ey gl Maal odds Of pylaey AIK! TE Clie Joy ly VY) Hhidly Bal Glee 3B Gas Y cb 5 20 Ob bd ye pael Ay "Lod ole" eS Lary cpteddly Gos all ISA Bendy Teel OVW ype pb par I 3b J lSall 5 pail Lia JEG ality tay pall le BY ol OV geld olay SLs PB Olde Spe aredl LUT Gla eV lis al 5 . Lass! Epo ys patdl, pM Ups Ghee Al opsteall 3 af Looe Lil" Lb Ly ybl pal cb lel seed gf ASS bled Cd CYL YG iJ sadly Spill Balad 5 SB gone, DW AT lee clei HU, Otel aul oa gle Last GLY ppl Ole pat Os penny haatodly PSM, Glidly Seles! olzell Late" 3 clad! Ab Epo Ky dla ours they Esa bey LY 65 OLY LISI yay BU] + Sad gl qlee Dye gh toy hell Bl gelly oy pil oC el phe os Of Livy . pail! Sd tga gl deat ttl oie] oP 08} GWE fay bee pM Gla Y -fily gertny lS orgs 5] GLI Glo Jooul aay aged fie ORE OL OSs ghoul REAM Gy tetl I bbe clad) 25 Oly ple Lary eg toll Of Manuel Maria Carrilho: rhétorique de la modernité, op. cit, p. 59. (1) Ch. Perelman... Traité de 'argumentation..., op. cit, p. 1. (2) Ch. Perelman, empire rhétorique..., op. cit, p. 10. (3) Ch. Perelman...: Traité de 'argumentation..., op. cit, p. 5. (4) 85aed Eyl eget) qbredb HU wg yD TY Lagio ye CAS dada! J JYsn4YU Les Topiques Lin shall 4b (3 silbrs JV last aad gil clgel ot pb Layee D pda AM ge WALI! gay Well gb LS Glow! Coed oe La oe SUI" YB ee dbs oo sh Lal Wad dhe Gd] Clb gag aster ory Od cle Vol de oli of 4s ae DIS i Qoinalls UUs Wale Gay le de Galery plans coir Rel AVE glee EB gS ys)l Coll pity Bie all lbs pests" od cpg GEN ado cle SE Olay cael de nd irked VIKay cqerenell A glte gy Dla 5aIl om gs LO" ebro [St jks Qa mll DB cderyesll SL day gtzbell dod! J epand Lnlall BAY cuts BE ONE st Loe LE 3% at gS" che! oyter OP pit BUI col Lg 8 igual BI! LG Gls Is Ihly ab ySll ye pall de LW gail fall 2b JB dedaald poleall yl BUSI fad CAS LS opps Glo led! pad Dae Y geilgell of de tle Gory gill he Uta SLI ot 1 15] cLoeelt of ol aa, Jo Hail WS oly gerernell BUS te, GES Cleedl Eby able w Sx at ALAS! Greed Jlosd OWyal! lea Jt all Debut io 52 Be ely Oe Ce Kay Oba Labs pill Leet Os 6 Qe Maglels gb golenlly (52 pil pS gLtl pS ell wil ple Cle Lay yoy cdgelae VI LS Zn LW asl gives Sst HUI, ollbsl Bale Gye Ube 3 clr yadb" OV oles) kil St juied Bled Dyhary tly] ely Wgisgboeed ool cpeod shee! po od sist a i ay ode QF ob ISIE paall call eo Yrbally glee Yl Gell Ibid, p. 7. (1) Ch. Perelman... Traité de largumentation..., op. cit, p. 10. (2) Byte ULSI clad 3 IIE gy Clty oilers obi clot" Dye alle (3) 2 BOT oy ySde conde, All ASME GF Clredl Ob pal ge “WKS aba) 86OB es UE OS Clhodl OB Dod! YB isle, POs haga BAM La] I las AG Kas OL e OF dd] yoy TED odin jay le pal af , qlredl y» Une nouvelle rhétorique tue 3 ASO ba ocd Lage mel Lai” "SL SSVI Lae” yo Carilho sgh S a J GSE UU OY Lady Ue Y! Gall Yuck SI, qe Fes ph Byes Nitely hing pe 2 cleo Lgl ope cl Galeul lille ee fran JSty LeglS 5 5s Ol py iy Hy iuliny Gotecey wiles G5sy Loe LS cle Lis ipall cilitlaie -2 Uke pat Ladd tele le BF pKa png GLY! Gabo) 05K gn GW Dubey talee ler ye JRF Obata! ode Yau! Leds Moral 3 Leal ss Gat!" gay gle ys lb Gs coy Alacra! gh EKeadI Still gf Supposés 12 pial! hed! dally HW oly pailly Lab OL LIL Glas y igi 22 Oars ye aL By rate ol I sf OL plo] Lp» :Les présomptions oLsI,3¥) 3 Spal er ytom rar Y yas sleet of YJ cisle Lal» Coy OpKiy Sls A HLL sts OLA SV; Oebed! JLo! bg 1 YY MLo My OVS pkey OL pds Oknd Leary cecrualt sf Ch. Perelman...: Traité de l'argumentation..., op. cit, p. 18. (1) p59. (2) Ch. Perelman...: Traité de l'argumentation..., op. p. 89. (3) Ibid, p. 91. (4) Ibid, p. 92. (5) Ibid, pp. 93-94. (6) 309 2 55d 6. clin a bI clad Typo Wl te (7) Manuel Maria Carrilho: thétorique de la modemité, op. 87Jeoledly BLAM gle! b clo nls pill fous :Valeurs pail! eh pyc gh tye GLH pd Greed GI edd ay aay helt le pares oballey the old WY US Cond pally Ll Mb Sh fe La geoer sf cGeully Jabali ft az Ll As Lge east (ga les tl ey Ley? pall Of sLes hiérarchies OL» ¢ll Dy thd ol pd ge fail ox AB Oe Jab aay Gesell pe ae gle laced G5 ab TALI! laadall gh dan yaroll, cLes lieux Oe gall J gall By eel jee bg Lag Fa pall Le cLevall Led Lenk sl ell qelpelly Ug UBL OFS AS stall eal yall ry cLieux de quantité Sl edly I Oi le pT pak bt YK Al Goal Gls (py ‘licux de qualité GSI ly age) Sails oth Tylée gare Jad st egg? lee asl sly - © GON de GLI hail a (pally lieux dordre 3 sly — Oe Pilly apse LLail aw Aly lieux dexistant » yx yall QAly LO forually errally Kast! le Grail St, deee Ls Glass Lieux essence 2 yl aly ~ OL ess BBY LLY by pt) ASsy db jy Leste gil el bedi! fea Ch. Perelman...: Traité de largumentation..., op. cit, pp. 100-101-102-103. Ibid, op. cit, p. 112. Ibid, p. 115. Ibid, p. 125. Ibid, p. 126. Ibid. 88 aM @Q) @) 6) ©)Cadres des accords lily jbT JX obotiall olay olor ely Cleo WE ope pe gil Leb Wlaadl § OW gall eet By clea ler Gilley slebe> YaeSiy Glesiel! sl olbrdl oda sll Bp jb lbaney orl Glade SalI eer dew pl Byted lb os Gay Jer Ugly hap leedll Gabe lag, 2S Legh y elstl hs duly pole let dey pal Glace" P "Glan" tay ll on ys gil BUST GB lay pte yards gebleall qoel yy Wl Ugbery debeal shan Yl deed tle SI arly Ope of] bleed IS3y Ob a hey BLY haus egll jp les ge Wad hie I Je alely Deals JLo Si ypal of pls lsdal sf olbaall CIS lay belt OB USL 8 le JU Gb op" Jo 55 att od ey DYUII Dead cp jhe ISIE HUD, totes OVW able Laake a5 cleedl 3 OSS cada pres gre Just od Clee ae yy wolediall slo! ge SLEW LLi) ie (ae YO" Gane So lek lhe 0,3" 45 UA, ae 935 Sp abdl LIK" OY dads Byte OLE Gey et Ws AY "Lie hl dex gl of Oberst Larcul be Lin Y reed! GSly GAS ppd gel tie skins linally yall Jan WIS Ly fe oly) Of pga) Kol goad sory: Tle Lad cord} Bs Lge id ye pe opSeg Bye B35 ca gl Gel patty Y Lrlae Lis olbasdl shit! obj sy Obed» my B]y aera (Sy bid ailbes Ys 0,5 Y cles gaye Leb ye RAS Opacedl yes raid dared 4B eghns} tay pall EU! Qe yU ols Ch. Perelman...: Traité de l'argumentation..., op. cit, p. 155. (1) Tbid, p. 161. (2) Ibid. (3) Ibid, p. 163. (4) 89Ai OB o> J} BI Jy od GL al 455» bbe Uys Tle Dad y LS Wyartdally JRA Ger frail lady Cheol b Linas Oly glad Al de brodl BW ye Jjre: LL ope lly Obed! Bly Waza! lati! J clea bak Wolke! Woe GLb ys OAR gy Ab US" OY ctl JS Ga de glee coal Lele tl bs gy sgpatnall SY jane pb 8 Sh 8 AI OL sid! pty eg liebe cll 55 OMFS Aly COSY i he gle ead G86 St LY ALG (G36) Ct LY ee pened Sol ol cp ewtll of LAY ope 5 Y Cre oP ches apd Beye Gb) CLI aL aly J eelill pares 31 Sl wade SLU Le gs bball a5 POs Abell gad GB Sood! pyar A le Of Ald ye Meads Reed sf Ub Jy Lob! BWYL GLY | MBE Obj y IK SS CANS gay cing LSh ay pall CIS ole BUY Cals uu" 5 cas poll J, Ep lard DY dale deli oda Cuy OMbab sy pall GIS ile WY OB Say Shee 3g lard Ganbeall pith thy phe Ge BY 0 gas FIRS 13 yd ee Obbal ys (oy ey Hy Gls! 3 SWY! jbl OigadieSd Keliall Ly pty dodoer dzlar Uraiel Latte drs yh BUI ge Del pall BLU fe Sy Ob > Clee pat Vy sbasl GY ope IG MUU, dpb Lo5 UUs 7s Y oi gl alll oder (AS JSS egleell ge JE gino lbs oper y VW ee: Me (BIT ge wy 9Sde 6. Silat « bt Geel dye Wie (2) Ch. Perelman...: Traité de l'argumentation..., op. cit, p. 194. (3) Ch. Perelman...: Traité de 'argumentation..., op. cit, p. 198. (4) Ibid. (5) Ibid, pp. 200-201. (6) Ibid, p. 200. (7) 90Welmed bbadey BWW jel WE Shs «gold! pall gb od lay FB rlre s9t: leat cll Ll KAW bo > Obi gall pany "go" ny (Modalités dexpression jd! gr ya: Lala diy wobbanst! fee of ghd Oly] le 2)" 4 chroull stue O55 Lene VY Joe Yay Brady US] Gerbeall pled ph call ye Deady OM pall LF oe Spar BB pe BY 6.05, TS IN) fee ba olay ales gpg bo oF abt Y GLI Gly SAN goblet a by dealt! GK! PSN yey peel 99d Cabs! Ob" colsaell ode taulyd bla aie OMI s3 J dy Gi oles! 3 UbLs ON ipl) me (GLU pall olor sald cleyees cle GY pie sy GEM aryl - cM ape SIE ye LA) jplinnss Injonctive (A1SY ae ydl- G 1G rS Eyles Haak 43 yrs cInterrogative plgizn Vl ar yall — & eg Gabel jalecll pail Sty uanky yay Optative atl ar yall - > AIST gt Le de pares olyt ge larulS debe slat ob at ay Bee ler pel ole J Glas tery opade UC Qa plead! ab gy ermal le sw (a Les clichés i) Salt Nl sLasel ge eas assy a aot pos SH USLed wacady pial Leal yasthady Ube lb grail poll Cae Balad LAY doll BLS AM 3 de jy diya dre del Con) gynetnell go DLE Ug Ug” OW gall La cel WY GEV Geos SLY (Solty las 8 sya Le 0" se aed jolt fo 5 . (1) 2) Ibid, pp 2 210-212. 3) Ibid, pp. 214-216. (4) Ch. Perelman...: Traité de largumentation..., op. cit, pp. 216-219. (5) Ibid, p. 223. (6) 91Wildate JS25 Quill LAjLtil Soy ary GUY be 67S 23 lp fest al OUT byl Vi Ma aid LS lbs (gb SY bg dpe cand oth (qlee! eB oye GEIS! pall lapel ce Vy ha iby Gl gad 5 35 OT ELS gad OURS gy 3 Lan of GL} Aspleat! cluiall -3 USS op Tb yell GLI AY eal cleat II Sy Ol Geel BLN od) GB pay Sy he gh lady rbel Aa cits! Glavy Uncomptabilité BUN\ p59 ad Cops poe Uh es FU i eal] dba Sls 055 Oty dey ey pal GEN See He bythe had Pay zl tnd GLEN OS WaLy Oe eM cdl ora BY Gate] stl poy Lee pally Sods dejo MAUI Go UYU QobY 1 by po Sy giles! (ail) Ley dengdall GU Ub pad OB Sy Bly al SY ge Shed 8548 ell gas VBE Ley dibs OL ALU ALLA ope ae owt ER tes core Ot NEN 25 EH Just JS OY plat pus of yj eydves clos (5 GLEY pd HUD, “GPM GLE A Salted NB) olasI Lhe 652 y0 ALB Lab y oll Be SS nisl pues odally WKY Legs fro GLY! Lay Oo MN des Vy oe9 ge ply He pgs V pcaliadly GeV y Clo yr gall tod Of in pally soot Ibid, p. 224. Ch. Perelman...: Pempire rhétorique..., op. cit, p. 13. Ch, Perelman...: Traité de 'argumentation..., op. cit, p. 270. Ibid, p. 276. Ch, Perelman...: Traité de 'argumentation..., op. cit, pp. 282-293. 92 Ww 2) QB) 4) (6)apd OY HS a beedl gyal) le IB pe fe Hala! I bi se VI US JRty LS seh oy SLL! pny WV Ebel Sow 9 ape of ULE US OSB Gally MY Lag st LM de lil deyt oat, clge pees Bell) Sod ole Kh - elt Bley bay dey ays - Syd BEAL pols! le 2h, AES aw - BIS pL abe ge em OS hs - gts SM OVLe Bhs ats ty ANANDA de LA Gopal - ON SI] ML: OVE ys ane Tales Pe SS lady uaey ae: Saad age YD oe) dyed Spd HUH OP po alll ase Jts OGY ASE pK p15 CAS 1) 2 pl Js gh Cant Gay bt Cou se MSS oe) 933 (SAS OB aye gmall Jal a SBS oe Lae jen a9 Arguments de transitivité &0\\ ee > ROU oe (OD peg Me yx gall GI OT OLY] gs SLE oda Ob CY I Gos Holy Te a sZt ee’ oy (Os (a CEs D ga SEY aye ye Goats BA AN eres aay QS ged A YSN G eyed Chak Geeell - Bg AST rel UT Oe ll le Gok JS le Geb Of ga whedon SHE os Epemall opr y le SY DEV, Ge jaca Clary le pd gall las Lead dG Maal, Chop — B28 HLM oe Gh He pp Ee Mode Litinll g ue Vides Ibid, p. 297. (1) B27 2 yds ssilillanny ol ign” po il te @) Ch. Perelman...: Traité de Nargumentation..., op. cit, p. 305. (3) Ibid, pp. 311-325. (4) 93PUgeles sf tle oI YEU Lod gp Ole yd pally LLY pe 9 eg sill Oe aS aplee OL ES CLI (ged ro gh copa - LEM SUEY pi yi dred ole Ley ley LW Wy OV deals Splall ax ye pK pe sisll of plans partly Usd / Jol ya Sb JHE adasly arith gloat - pla Wy tarsi Ke] ley alae 6d he es Gl adetll Bary Oleygde Ler Lem ge “Sheedy OLIYI" (ge ygie Olay eLailly SEY a gey SIS Y Ua xe Byiell oye LeLIYI is as dem go.y Argument dlautorité WN to - Be 09S IB geld fT eee Gola Jee Leper aShe GU of LMI GT a ta, a5 dat olay Le ey bh dee le tl OMagasl h "pba gL" gl "ple yi" i elo SAG Analogic Jay Mlustration MszN\y Liexemple Judy good ~ oF 23) Ee pty oldie dole ed deg Y (pl OYbU! 3 pte BCE el J oslgiy fell ogb wy Lat doe IL QJ) io UL tlagle GY alten OB Kol sT Reh Gay fea IIS Lafy ute Jae UD gail Bey ptem Usily Al Spi and gy Grraill axle OY Us phar OIF fy UA GLE Nal de pyis OY Soler abel Joos 1 JES 5 May hae Ii Liles OV Lee op 554 orks fas oS otf a [41 41 Se Bay] ° 428 093 bs Lyd 42 (Ssh 25 o Zh gil by & Ibid, p. 326. (1) 1334 ye (Se ...aililliny o bl Coed Dye ae (2) 335 ye wed (3) 337 Go end (4) 339 yo tad (5) 94TH tin soll Hog Zautily 93 Stes 4d1l 94 a lool Faun (A clea gg pce ga Sela} -1 id} Lex» ANSCOMBRE 5-4 Sly DUCROT 4 -S9 dLocl ux AUSTIN gas] ue 1 Al JUGS 2 Jb pe pl Ayla] OLY BENVENISTE cuit) let] Seu! au J} 2-5 LS SEARLE Jy 5 te gyda ULecl Jey -BAKHTINE goth Gylye lly deal Sp> Olas pz UIS BL Say bole B31) oe CLesdl QyL5 Late LJ LL Jogig GRIZE pS OWS Wily BL U5 Conall a de West KS, A OB c garded htt Lalo ge Epo yl Lele 3 Lite 5 BOREL Boegh as” WLI a pe ST, 4 Soo Latacel (pl BUI clroul LL y GLY jae Gabe) dada LUI y Ge all & AU OUI Otel Shia gf aw A le Clas ely ad lll pO] sal, GUI grees! asi!” Loe Gp eg lbY) Sl yg ae ool pod ey EM Waa lb 3B fod aU OT A Lest Wy 2" SUN odd gpa! LSI alge] Daas bya gay Uyd rene SLE Ges pee apd Lal Lore grb Lele oe pais YSLSM saad ob oes \gal claall 5529 Pragmatique intégrée Asad) Ay shail! -2 bball DW by 2) Hy lul OF & BI ode J lala WI 2 (GSI ae) “Led gd JEW yy gd! OULU Erbe tN" sgl Sy} (D 2124 yo 11994 dae y 619 sal JC Anscombre et Oswald Ducrot: "“Argumentativité et informativité", Dans: De la (2) métaphysique a la rhétorique, op. cit, p. 79. 95Lol ese Cad oP AY 3 ete Vise Y (ob ala olicll, ASLAUI Gb jb odes (gl Js / gill Gall dbaby pt yey Ly Sb Lag Hee Sb gee I as tere lb gill Ya ls J Bla feel) Gam Teak Cond OU Kal abe Of Syl ges DVL ay ooolig alias sonted EM Ol tye ology gaye JR fare byile JS Whee ype db fora dye pra Bile JS ope 59 gaall Lig al cb pth ip wees ai — 1p dye Lead alld US, OY ey bb Ne Ghd Meal obs of 5 deta Lyla obs Gels rey Pag pad Ol 99 qeiliall Ke SLE! ole! PVM sadly Solel ded get eas Y GU! BLU cl Lis 3} CAB Al Ded Bb ey byte ot nw” OF 5p 9 So foe Gls! 53 Geog OF gk V- dyes ASV gl - ns SY Upeggie GISU Yd OBA tae Olaie slarcel Baad bse gaall OV cid slilly DVM ga jlo eats UU Lag HY glacll JRA as Hl ila doors LbES ib yy oe bab Gl Bylo LSI dae das Pl SYA & tl" eel LO" gaat stb] ed gph a SLE Cd EU dnge OB Syl! 9 pall Le iy has Vel Sind Sy od Gill Jtedy GL LY ey oye BUI OF gay bee ob ainy VE gaily ily os Ajku] 53 ob Yl C9 GL Gand AI LoS! lela Yl os Legere” ple JS ganas PP Moly bs GU O55 OF SB 3 yKe Vy. LIY OUI 3S Jacques Moeschler: Argumentation et conversation: éléments pour une analyse (1) pragmatique du discours, Paris, Hatier ~ crédif, Aodt 1985, p. 75. Oswald Ducrot: les échelles argumentatives, op. cit, p. 8. (2) FL MB gy tebe Spo BU 3 Lala iyo glu Gb DVL 65,5 tol (3) 189 2 2000 pea eJsVI dadall «tS 96ead oer dh Gat tA UST id Lely Ge YI Of Lgl! Js Mae pel danas Medi CI iy LBW Gye, AI Get Ed candy JR IEW Goal GLU Gpmell gb La dte LU yglad al pall Cals Ly Se oe USe pa Snily 4 So she dey ALG Fal yay clroul of ele 03) pe Glredl -Wlgr sis Edt ode Glade Uele 255 od AU EI B Coed pe pally LOU! Obie WLAT 3) & Lot obs gd yay UI yd Uhl tele Golt le Liye y phy phabll LSE aU NV yr gebrodll lb aL] le ib od ghey bp ilell of" 5 Se OSs ol de Les Blly Label OL Lee VI ote Y thsi clasdl Lia af DSP Set A Ge ABE Se Gp OUI by JG Qed Jeb Ete OLjLeel 432 JsYG .Argumentation broly Raisonnement dia! SY20I oy Be 68 Berle AS lbs!) SII le ole Bly Ghat BP bles OSs pS JK cuted ys lado Lei ball le 52 pi ol" OY, Age 6 pay sf tee ins Chill oe of GLE 3 OMe pols Lal 5 stow plist! Ls Of «olba Les LU cles! pte 9 So Ub 28h lh SI OU SAI ge eke OUST guy tare clgerly Glbsl Ve J GUO Kall arg" LS alert jae alle J ay datowe "SS gh ces! Ved dy Gg Uyf dibs JSS ll Erledll Heb yl Of pele Serb SLLS slag!" jr Sely 9S ee a LL gt 1422 sine bb M25 LS fala tee SLIT 38s pA ALL ssl S yt (1) 1135 yo «2001 ge Oswald Ducrot: les échelles argumentatives, op. cit, p. 16. (2) Oswald Ducrot: les échelles argumentatives, op. cit, p. 12. (3) Ibid, p. 10. (4) 97Yate, SLB ge Olio chil” ye 03) BUI 3 chrod! 0,55 0" lbs qld OB lee Migs 2" eitall Ute, a FU leans ero! dhe Why ge Dead celal ee of ole oP days pt GW OLS oy ales YI La 3 bul ar gy i pele oor 8 ese!" J ghey! O's sf ASG 5 ptlill gs thar le WU 5 cleod! Lb Gags aprbredl cles Vy Erleell Ql pally Serbreall Bal) pr Alia olay A gre dllly Erbe idly Aslaatl diyatt -3 (oe ee LSM gy as Yo Le Ll ole 5 cleell df Gt Glginn ge yan gee Ug) (ASeaSI pd de perked Jit! [Jil Nis OS el yee dae dy, CAT Dy Syl de ball Joe Se od VI der lredl ea’ SLY ode St Vy Lee gl Lew pe teed P WAS 045 VAG GLI ia 3 dee 055% at Sey Lai" gow GL Fait aodl nity oh pall Grea! We pW Glo Wy > el dle OND gal Jels ae roll plod BIS! od g/d BVLy ered /dl LBM ge 03] BALI af Alpi bss bs op ell Pl Y! YaSou Y Eyles Bde Ay Spedlpall eda Ge LS irtrodl Alaa qual gall 4 [35 gle J dm | gibe go glad) SUE OB pe Sly 9,59 captecens eblye Le Ug (lel Gall! eealeall gy Dear Gb pe dt 125 go Se CLA US Elrod LS!" yest S ol (1D 125 ye tdi (2) Oswald Ducrot: les échelles argumentatives, op. cit, p. 15. (3) HAZ Gyo eg sSde MOLI 385 (ASI aL” gol So) 4 98PU Raby Clroll aber ga cleraic aslyelly TOPO! | wget Law I Le spi (Communément Lelor J yie inle Lol Ugi] ge trodl bL2 gle (iy iy Me Rnd pp) pKa Gb oye Updcall Aged” Kas cadmises) dye lbs Erle Be JS ot gar Gi AW OY as aber hd De grleod! SUEY fb date Le LL oh tmcilly Ged ge oy as 039 Gd ys Goda Hs gy La pb O39 Gpae pls gb Ls Lee SLY Oo" halt Glelae Sled] Seal ye fart Lale Lely 03] Cal yell df plex Aye dns Upl gl cLes lieux communs & xt gle) p25 05 sand IKE US Sf rst gb old Calgall ociay tne Lary petree f WE Qe syell Yard Gatlasl ole lists dalam dike yoo Jil of ash veiled DV tooled Whee dlars SS pb gay Sly ae -Orientation argumentative (20+ (grle> sled sll oy cel gol Lasts Sglrodl bo! ya LS we plaalll oles -5 L938 call yo WRAL, te lbs LLG ete chou O51 EE fipks Ub LS gyre olell abel ge ebro a gl OB wolelel Erbe COYLE Gets Tee Gil ee Ls of te Vy cotow BLS getty et Lie UL 4 AU! Aol coded cane oLanl (gi Lao gi Sai aby dase Ua ploy JSt5 Marqueurs argumentatifs 42la> selene 3 SUI! ahs ales a2 J Marqueurs argumentatifs 4salaadl gil fll -6 Jacques Moeschler: Argumentation et conservation..., op. eit, p. 60. (1) J-C, Anscombre et Oswald Ducrot: “Argumentativité et informativi Gnd All ASI gb cled! ob be pal ae ia PONE esa gS GB) 380 yo 15a 99Wes As ig) pole (5 ‘Les opérateurs argumentatifs Lrbyd! Jl lal - 1 ly pardIS dol Lp OU Se Sep ber 5 rare Hips dob] Gyeu) Potentialités ilo! UY a> A lgabyy bly Mined i BUI 3 pewPresque tame fo dghpsy ob yilell CSD oS ge bp Wy UA OLS perked bays o leat ye beth ead tee ely tle desl eel B oth lie ay (gredl on eer on Jl inty Ge gx) Eebod! CongSS OY) ee err Byte Lely - Godel D3) fee SL bp pte Lays - oe tar ep Ablael Cand tnclly Geol ou GSI OF ce yor s less) Upll Ol td Sod ar 8 La classe argumentative (staal) audill -7 B plScall aes Ot ge paleo! pil opraall O18 959 a CB DIES gyre Ler pony (259 1G) os O29 I] ee pile le Hdl pal WS Gere Bhai le pg grlredl pil OB gd ox orc ee he OV Es teh 8 rel al OT I Se ty wdoly IL ply Hel Vy Ley lM dns il) AS yd edly pl ns sl pS gle do sad lg ogll ile dade ¢y Soe BY, (251K Ogres! pill La force argumentative Ayala 6 sill -8 Up bad B55 LGY Cyl Gerbrodl nil td Late avd! Of J-C Anscombre, et O, Ducrot, "L'argumentation dans la langue", Langages, N°42 (1) Didier Larousse, juin 1976, pp. 8-9. Oswald Ducrot: les échelles argumentatives, op. cit, p. 17. (2) Jacques Moeschler, et Anne Reboul: Dictionnaire encyclopédique de pragmatique, Seuil, (3) Octobre 1994, p. 281. 100P red Sd Gol bing Lins Grr y ed ere Ug GUL Lid Whine ddaray oly Hall GIG] Lael CLAW GG claw OS Le JB gle gals reall le Gaol sLaceld Leal Shy Lpalecall coal U Ll ola LOLs i Vy tell 55" y Ko pit LS Lael sla dl seaslill LS sal ab 1 2S opie WS Oley DHL eel gg Lgl d! LIL of vet bredll philly olan Le cand HDLll oda tes Echelle argumentative ;,a\qa alul! -9 ted (Gre) Sed Be le Gps lee Jiro il" 5 So Uy eprbeed fied Gai yak 9d Lee Groat Ob pay le OL LL FAS AbUaSIL LUI Nigh 559 fee tay bebe LL oS incr PSV deed pl pg te ry P BM dna p peg tee AY I peal UL" ys ie 5S Sy py gist a Jobe Méme,) alo! duly ji nae Jat Les «(Petit-grand) HSI) ot tal (Mais, Presque... Cee dl Ae ab 3 SII ste 65 ,So Shy Y gan IY dlerl by AB Dy Baye LG oe BIW po Le yar” GS gerbe! Li Lond Gab AU i pay OF (55 ey ed as be pj pl go be tie J es dod JS Ot - Oswald Ducrot: les échelles argumentatives, op. cit, p. 17. (1) Ibid, p. 18. (2) 101GPM AGM gear he GI 3 opr sell dill Ds Aap age, le OS cgure sls le Wb IS pL LB Js JS at - OS st glee Say lar Mage cb 55a Leatecel 3! UY 2plwly 531 BI UISVI LASIIY dalgtdl ode 5 yaar - Atl Balgstl Ge 25 Gear - SLE YN doled le a5 rer - wdgaball yj BUS A gle Jared lel JS bee YUpT LS tills Cad gered OF prleol pholl JE ge 15] eas Speedy ots VLD abel ob gu bes clings 35 Gust fp GIL oda shel yay ge Waly 05 go elt UL acigllee Gary Syl Gul sous dees I HL HG sl deol 2105-104 Go Go Se GIS phe aytaay Io Jpol J ihm pe ab (1) 310 yo Sie CEB Cleo LB" Soll GK Q) 102Halli £40 soll Malady dling qlaall gf silo litte tla Slide 6.9 pita J ga Sela) -1 re Lpadey eS 9 danke ood Sed ate ile Lites Ja Cored Ll 99S ral Geng Gree WIS yay HW A) Poll place ule oil Jolis ell a SY Ball OlbiT Ls ley seme idlaeall creda gy Ja pte Kabul 29d! pL WL ally CUS ogo AST OM Jat) SBI" pony Logos Go yo gl Ob aetsl poet Sales oF gSay Vda jneny bitin dol ple dLtas dtpoll B pall of healt OF sae i] fp MEIN, BLU SLY goles Jalgll tes! UF Nope cn tal Oa 3 LEW Laedly BSI jal ey Gab Sales hp B98 PAM O Kal Lee ees HOD yy gM Lineal Dai cdg ila liza (phil! ¢ 9 ptiall -2 bbe 5,6 dey gM! ial OF ys GSW coy te B pl Gly dl Shy aU etl of pall I) ol gy tal all as dee alee eth) al le Lia ode olell J ey pad Bg WU apy Gell CF pe hey geerT die Ybe od Ce il ally (adbsll pues Souls "ESS UI" Tyg An WU jyled Ulta, Aan pl JB ZK gy Hall ul Las sf IK Co Ae NL abe Of «Sis Aad O Sally gala yo Michel Meyer: De la problématologie, philosophie, science cl langage, paris, le livre (1) de poche, 1994, p. 231. Michel Meyer: "Pour une anthropologic rhétorique", Dans: De la métaphysique @ la (2) thétorique..., op. cit, pp. 128-129, 103LSI soy aggetall JSS Gey gaat DeLn gh Ab idler ob sill IS LASS OM Sal) ILS] dno” VY pd GIS All GIB QA Ug gay QIU 0455 Bo gall” Of i rall GUIS LAS s ColLsI) gh OLA OLN pa, 3" lf Bagate Clb Fay 9 Vl ed! of GET ead dy Yost de WY LST OILY PLY! play BB Stead pla ode lead day, 9Vl Lal Le 5) Gute 4 Ose!) EyLaadl ode B lee Sally Dyrrred Gola! le oy all bh dst Tee GUI GEM 53 ge aya Sle City slizdly gaodly pate pes her) Sled) oti ode ag Lyall ELS | A al Gel pols mole dey GB ggg ME gd UM digg pol Lt gp 03] Ley TL a OF gb ote, gle ao phar GH! frtdly Lasse) pili wey gh Way MSE / Atal el er ped Oly HeLa) JVI edb eds o1SSY De la Problématologic tS (pyle Ltr gar 11986 t~ lS ace y LD! ol SIE aT sel teow (lil B yall ay JS BobaYI poe GUI pW SIA ge ted Lyles of ST UU) ALB! LyeN yey cLe critére propositionnel’ 5 pail jaa! pe 13 pall WGLESVy Coed! yb UAW obed, OUI Ls JIRA, TLS PH 2535 3329 SH gp Lab! Ole] rl Ley pen V oe TL cepa KG JVs Lie y ght «Sill Wa lie Geet pa Gps dpa oe ely elem" sell Lobe fasile Gs Gam 4b Gye GUI EU Cpa NL gv epropositionalisme Ibid. (2) Michel Meyer: “pour une anthropologie rhétorique", Dans: De la métaphysique & la (3) thétorique..., op. cit, p. 129. Ibid, pp. 138-140. (4) 104LO" Joresll Bhs Gane [eg Sal] LU ote Badly HOY Th ee nl ty Lee Sill OL LS Ge BL yl Lt pany date 35 mall odie OSG gory IKI Ul heb anes sh ipo Jie Wel gs eV UY vb Pp MLA Of tO Lod! DEL gu Y led" WU, GLAST + ASA blab py Le le Le je Lae Sa aS Vy Gay La SY GW pl Lt ay ageVi ge ULI Gre! of .©)"différence problématologique ot ed SIS SOM pole UL j glee odes! ctl Lig Dell pol of" UUs Ledye Uy SIR /UIZU dls iS > Bad IBY O) AbG dyad Bast yl) GlbsU ibd! eld he Lal 3] (ge ban (he og lates UL Ob Loles SLAY pe GL Lat Ode SI gle lta Lb! Chel SP RIBS! IU ge JEW py Sill Jb Velie! olecel of pls SLA De 3 ged es OF US gSe Y Sl ode Giy AUG OSI LO" EW wets Vides eb UL ol pl Slt pty A ALS Hy ZIG cel ajee Baal) ied I [Deland af oobi cea bas Y clalacal 0 fe WE pt dt W Miny ol yall Manuel maria Carrilho: "Conséquences de la problématologie”, Dans: Argumentation ‘et questionnement, sous Ia direction de Corinne Hoogaert, PU.F 1996, p. 75. a Soe ode oe G5 4b IS JS" Proposition Hal 3 "Lhe oer" Jy (Sally ale pret gay etl dayl gall tte Gad YS fy lS I Gre 9S Ky pall BUY Aoki pall OGpdead eV ode Slabs Selly GaSoll Lats oe, 6 Uo pad 61994 - 91414 ye SU IWS Wy Bey HH, 7 195-196 52 Michel Meyer: De la problématologie, op. cit, p. 236. (2) Michel Meyer: "Pour une anthropologie rhétorique", op. cit, p. 138. (3) Michel Meyer: De la problématologie, op. cit, p. 305. (4) Ibid, p. 354. (5) 105LO" haa odad Spolead AU" aeay Kt odes WY slash ais Shel Jas (4g) HUD orally +I Lael pte 03] UL py ti 9 ALAM SY) wolpadly Sd sls Ge Bf sled Glell tye JLts Jyb Sete ty 0, SLATE) bs Ge LS LOO RG 18d egal Spe dey te wala lds gg dia ob Sina ll y dtl! -3 Lagi, cu Le Le probléme JStally Jp! ge ple Jt by» Beare oh pele 2 Spe YS" OL eS" a 8 Gis JI labs MaLeatt OT le ter sang OLS S181 I elas Ill yg Slt Bay po AAT OYolall JSy dba! SU;lsY JS ahi BUI 5 Usk Lok OF ple Lt ae ge Wb ages Dead oye US "Ye ge glll" po LS ODeLwed Wler VY nd gles buat" BSA Eel odey AS ge LS ddlery JIE 5,0] BUG Sad Qo BLY OS poy Opt AWE ag Ad) BLEW pal LY! Lo [cpa GL Slane!” oye ors Lew UG gdh of pele Cb I aN, LO" JStba) e wy AAU ad) el Ste ole oe Gill ppall Mas Qs Lb nily MN ohye [Spee teas ge AU LL tte II" ena EWN, GEV wa Y] Sut Vy vale Sldiae 6.9 pia Cauda elaall —4 leds Gh SoM! I} pl Lt ted cla ob J Michel Meyer: “Pour une anthropologie rhétorique", op. cit, p. 131. (1) Michel Meyer: De la problématologie, op. cit, p. 259. (2) Michel Meyer: Logique, langage et argumentation, Paris, Hachette, 1982, p. 124. (3) Michel Meyer: De la Problématologie, op. cit, p. 238. (4) Michel Meyer: Logique, Langage et argumentation, op. cit, p. 122. (5) Ibid, p. 123. (6) 106ar pall egSls Lee GS dp cplglon Ml 2 ree He ils J al YJ cdl wp AB gh J IS LBB Say Irs Delo! (8 dydrdl by prey by Oo gles LIN Ob yds ote Sly CSS! Lat GI ETHOS 291 - GAS BLS SV REY, EW cleat! gi LE PATHOS (sll - wagers OP Sy DLW yydrell GUS JS t Glee] LOGOS jo 54 Ul - = Sp = GREW FT ned ob ST LS J OWS WI ods Je le PST JRAT Dlad po IS Wy SIAR dey OL FV SES Ay Ol yel .Négociation 14 list! Lia 2st Jatil ple ols Adhésion i359! hay WS (Sl ob pal aS y~ HL JR BIN OP pl my sahil DURST Slaatel ax st a Yond ye OY lll yey Mundi ge OLY! OMG LS JVI Wy gl LS pil Uy pbb LS ley! Uy" B tod SLRS ty hel J ppt Lee ol I Gg ot HUD (Pil taaSly dally tot arly lpeud LLG eile Laylee algglas Las Y oleerpeall 2 935 M fecoealt a Lo 5 LGN arlee WO, Y Led all Le Cl ob pay dolar Wy SIE iL gl ZLIYl led SeIly pd sey Oserl ge" LI Of IS atoll pgrclyes BLE, gl yy prt) gy laser gry Hate [ge al] OKs ge Op tag Sl le PS GLI el sl Waa eat od fats af ceed Lege OV ake Ogle dyelKe Lace Geltl Of Loge Ghany SAV SSL OS ctordl dulys Gly UL Wa pgrly Oyrrby glides JSS plas GF Gil ylt ait) RAM /I pull dalled Bye Joly jad Michel Meyer: Introduction a Aristote, Rhétorique, op. cit, p. 5. (I) Ibid, p. 6. (2) 107cally Ady OUT YS dharlne Uprly 46 pnd se le gp toe OMeLa] ge” aS Lad clr! pb Ge Wi, ee chee OB abel! Oy ge BLinll aur 3 Uelacl! CAS Hi] ghas Cabsdeall bay la peed Ly] eld] ae gh Lisl aig La slie ga yl alse Geaniy gable qarly Yam Pls pte SU Igelye JS leg ech gly BLS Ls lie Cleo! dba, df GALES ai & pat yall SLB" Oe 3) pe tiilyay ott OLS he 3 Lei] NST YY Shea day pS aust ge yet Lyedy LeU VI Wyayy ped pbil of He dyed SAW ISB Sly porns Bry Opntlice 3 Wyle ON stall eal pgbdeHl dye (2 5ledl Pa all pe GLY Jil daa glin ge Ley cles! pes Se Cem IL 4S phheny TU yeild oleh Ged ptheall poLeial he JS GY A etl hall SLA ge JS Lad tall clos! OM Jatzell food” ols AN yall HY Cab by ll cleo dag] zl iy bral lbs Labasy ce pall lp ad sila Gelb pSu Feel} Ce eel ed SI Alb elyy Get OK] ge Coed Ger ey Lee Bylbs cleodl 65 Jost ayy LS) ae W/W oaegy ests AY glee J inal SH ant yd ph bay coll “ad sl," danas de> bull si Byte DT ys UU, Le ale (5 Lied! oltty orbit peas CY, "3 oe Bas lly (Asal LO Saeed OF ny 935 ON" pyle Jyiz WS By Yur Michel Meyer: Logique, Langue et argumentation , op. cit, p. 136. (1) Michel Meyer: Introduction a Aristote, Rhétorique, op. cit, p. 40. (2) Michel Meyer: “les fondements de T'argumentation", Dans:Argumentation et (3) questionnement..., op. cit, p. 18. Michel Meyer: Introduction a Aristote, Rhétorique, op. cit, p. 47. (4) 108cdedlyll 21s soll jlgoll dinlaog sliigy Alle cgplgall Meg dle 6.9 pia Uiga Se bial -1 Jacques Moeschler 15 yo Sle Gi) 56 ceaS sl dee yall pW suet 1p claw golts Seles Jol cn pole dyslouslly chou! Ullatly Eddy Roulet Jy) gb) Jy> Cabs Jl ize Leyte Slecl iyglestl de 655 pl Unley 1972 Searle Jy 61970 Austin gx gh LAU! 4G ULecl 1979 Grice B Coed Lager Lelul Ducrot 4-525 Anscombre jr Xf SLocl lange AI debredly Syl] OLE ge GAS gill I Gad! LURE les op Eye yall Le stan de pd ye ylides gb AI poll Le] Sye ObUasS WE 10 8 SLU dIS BB 4,28! Syl pl Ved gets ll ie ee op ge OG OL lbssl pre sf Lead BT ed sitll syed ob Catt 5 Godt CLUS oo abut Lb Hbcdeadl Obed 94S of Wis catty Obed aicel" Lt yo J gis Lola aed gp ySsteall oF tg, cdl Ws gall Lie 3 Bll Ob] ad) Ba Kae ree Ally dalal Hell ye cues oud Operas gyi tt Mash 2ST LEW oud sash lee gb! 43 ph «al Jelell ge Eg ga be ye i par LS spall of Jacques Moeschler: Argumentation et conversation: Eléments pour une analyse pragmatique du discours, op. cit, p. 187. Ibid. 109 BN deg bpd sli, ly aed ppd le LW Il ity lylabew ol" () Q)ON Igle J] Sy2s! ese Dig ge Nye GY USA) SUKI OP oy Cary Liéchange Wate - 1 Lintervention U+\.5I- L'acte de langage pas sb Joa - fe peal Ke) FISY 2392) oral yanks ot BV Ube 0,55 Val alls St OSs O38) ged guiledes (POSS ry Dalal UKs “Ex yyiy” toy ST gd Ustad Ll pail 13] Hagen gf SLD oda yd coded 1B] Sy Le] O55 y eT SLT See) Loli Leal JSE5 Ball ge Sal le ty ye ely le ips Dale dle 3 ow Viger bof Sola idl 3 pV La ols Nay gS RU fod del Ute del yiye Bory pool pl Jeb ara: sf ..Ly)eel gf Lott of ASL hgall cf Maly -2 Sot S on OMolelI dy pb oy joors Confirmatifs 256) 413] oYole - Réparateurs (iva 3) 41, Yale - oy I CB Mole al ccaty Gale ll ay SI BY Vol aIE Le Ldny dell pte dont Catly Is Sle Ge Op SH Ll Joti! TOW SVE oni, sol cle U9 Jescall - cdl Clee lll Jour - sgl Ibid, pp. 81-83. (2) 110FM GS JVI Joust - Sealy St se gl foal - Ap flee SLI Obi oe S13 oYolall oda GLE L Wey Gt Sergey Jol) bash yey Le Soe JG LIZ VoL aly Sal AsloeV! daly Sky oL3VI Vee Yala ge eT Legs Lt ye joer LBM OVoLAI Cie Jl CFV lee Goll Shgsit pag Le he 2.5 OL JI 5,535 Réparateurs: 4,1, et fe Dad) plo OF dy MS es Lees LG LT qos ea oJ AU gels VCS) Gere ema CD Sg OO) Gadel et tere Abe Tile] a 3 ge) pad ttl op Se slice Jad of polis O51 AN 5) Mb y Clady gece all rill Lin OB gt gery i pal Wal yall go Leg Kery Valoll 3 gS leat oe Lala VoL SI das ye Vaal pd I dat OS Hy Hal eV ls Vata oe GAT el eT YES WF Ol, sleet! ofp cLindaires OY otaII JR ay legety LAL SM GYabal 5+ 05 cEnchassés Cre Vale" tlgioy joy (gi pvs céchanges parenthétiques “sw 3 go Th Deadly Uecle fis LS LO g sl alee Gane gts Al: Quelle heure est-il? LOW Ci pS - Bl: vous n'avez pas de montre? Cael. Hh cdi - A2: Non Yysuty - B2: Il est midi bell Gnas I pots Ug) - A3: Merci? ise - Of BF sl ze Dalolly ALeV Dole! cus el (BI-A2) DoS Allg BF GBIIL S heb Ply be Jacques Moeschler: Argumentation et conversation: Eléments pour une analyse (1) pragmatique du discours, op. cit, p. 84. Ibid. (2) 111échanges "LAN Vola” ya eT Ey Jp HUIS Uateall dy goes AGB) Hage 9 SF olga gl clged BWI THN! OY Lis ay .négatifs Jayde Bil sf Fy yet JLo sY LAW] gle ot als yo itl Ol pall wa pol lgall cgi Aus laall -3 ed Ga AS poll Dele J hy jem dead Joli! rey GUI O yall pay dlacte conducteur az yal ral - i LOMA pall geall car LY oye seers sf Eacgell LLylill (AScall lee ee Al ILS gay Gael!) Ly LEY / palo odLal tebusdly ar yell Jaill 2,2) yl ast AWW JB 2 UKs ISAs ax yall Jail Of GabS! JG GE ley .Non supprimable +l! (3 Lb SN ge Greg Ebel Gly go glad OHA! Of ote te OL Cs I ot lal se" pty aa) Gilby - SNBY bby sl ab 0S Lyle Gb I ey OM bia! wee Vly Bey Yo pally GLIV Lath JStsy wdaeles VI OHS L555 py eS 3) Uhss ) tb - OUIYY satisfaction Lo, Yl Jala gp odody dy A yell ill we Sta orend SN] SelG Hib I pnts webbie! Ga fred dar ye 215) alby - i weedy bead Lo jkr /GIE fond Whe Salus)! lb y- o Tid, p. 188. (2) Jacques Moeschler: Argumentation et conversation: Eléments pour une analyse (3) pragmatique du discours, op. cit, p. 94. Ibid. (4) 112algal acl gi -4 POH syed tele Le ye otoy Adele els - why dels = webs bis} sels - ots Aly hele Vi decd OI toolell GB Lodey ELelis sel abs ABW GB del sill oka Ne ye Gates Gilyeall adh) Lie bles lg obi ll Ady GEV call pil ULE Ups GS sbtall pF Sygloue cal" ob Lake "Face age y ttgi py 2M Stns thal pat ll yyibll Ly dale JS OF as cog psging ou, sl eo gl Olas Jade seul jl ab PAB he I pardl B Geld cy prs [Whee ble Ble ye ey a Vl Ob Like ay sled! Ob y= Ses cll 48 structurelles & 521 sel a Ul ISS ty ey Ll ebby Joleall poll abs 2M ode LAS edger oe JOU! Dol per op yslertall pjl5 3} cle go je Wl] Ces ay yles pW ya Dold GHEY SIS bly OGL Col ee ret SHE] tye gay cL De Qe Lyol,YI UE LW bell -Stratégies de résolution®) "Jo! oles! cul". Voll Tyga! J OSs gl Of Satisfaction La ,Vy Lb gld Labs Di tY" ling EPI ES Oo we (3 Ub Seey JL LU ys Gale gl Sshpol LSteU Kewell oll lis toy Le ga Om lt lbh Apu dat et gf 3» so05 .cohérent et cohésif pally p>DUl Jacques Moeschler: Argumentation et conversation: Eléments pour me analyse (1) Pragmatique du discours, op. cit, p. 112. Ibid, p. 113. (2) Ibid. (3) Ibid, pp. 115-117. (4) 113LL! PLAY! gals VO Sall ple Gey yay Ke ge pl) Sea bee oe 2h bi ing GIDE Dy Kal) plladell Ey yal! pts cathy DE Yy WLS! Uy bas dF gal V O Soll le W254 p43 6G pH Dyno be GIN OSI Ge BVI J Gals of Dac of ails Be ah SS Ui yy (LOY geld WI OsSalh le Gab sAy 4 ghS bah Ci shat GSS TB y OP Wad gE OKall B Ug pda alba be Cab gl ype Bie OB Kelp) LIS by er da ghee sf Le bs Lin ol tye Body Gl past path OLE 4 pads wees Wjer Sige gly Lege Gage OU Sey sles erly 8 ela yl Ip Ky at pole NM Dy Kal gle Go pk phy agreed Mab p* . Si dot AM esl dls Lm ug al Oy Kal e+ Lele be slo sY Oe By glaall cf claall 5 Galas" BY clredl 48 ge eine oSey Y iyybreld Jabs ga Pr Cle) RELY Slat Skreall Of op Elna) oi iby ply le GB Bally Dela ise te le Jub JS cle betas asbudt say gloedd! Halal Ly (A gleall -1.5 Nate pe” Nae ye grb! USL 2 ying Uthat! polish sou: be Of ae bby ke eM le ey iets! ly gr lbed! dyae deed aii le alezel ad lw gored ge (UU Seal ot Ged” = Jacques Moeschler: Argumentation et conversation: Eléments pour une analyse (1) pragmatique du discours, op. cit, p. 119. 114Onl add Ltt ag Say Y dbo bes Oke - TALUS plrenil gay GHW leo ples Yl aiiry Lay! Liay Faly NM oday cle daly MN gents (II doled Ol Le Hel dled - Arey aly sill daly) Lid ogrleedll Leet) Ce Gs UII pl Leds Gere pe be Gd daly J olny gly OLY Upeleil obS Met pad OF ey Cee Lgl LL aslo = OF GEE by ys Gabbly YLasls 5 Ulews eld S pS BLU last Cals Ue tyke LIS ps" of alt ys biti hig DEY MSH ge Woy Label iy Lely 3B ASI IS > 3). ULG plat patos eed pean" rl tel BLY, Processus 5,5, GY wolails ahh Ogle foley ole bslasel dels Glut Gold be plSted garaiall [SM SAT ge Aya Game LS eats LS yo Ute glob Lites eer bed LSVy Loedll Lyd alee OL Ss Lge y fe MSI Mingly dee be se Uslisll 3 clei of pe bY ty aL af Peters orIenly lye] ge ST > ool bAU ELI pall Mahal ay of glaall -2.5 thes gi Alb ye tle Uae UY clredl gig Cloture GYEYI - Expansion ail - Ibid, p. 121. (1) Ibid, p. 131. (2) Ibid, 135. (3) Ibid, p. 139. (4) Jacques Moeschler: Argumentation et conversation: Eléments pour une analyse (5) pragmatique du discours, op. cit, p. 149. 115ge thats bers ala gd Se gale Jol gl Ob eet ony pegs meg Aol gall) Bath 38) (DEW Usle 3s iy sail ys Le glisll cin’ a ll Ll Accord GUY! J nary Giese SLY" ob .O"Négociation oul A GdeY Sb] Llp! Doball J claod! Hibs Gaol of Cel pa Vs code N galt petrol pla wl Gebd elas Ryled Opell aed SGT ace Coed) Gel Ole pul 5,5 ob Lie wlan lees Adalyall Gel y glaall - \ lath cy (LI Gad 2 UstLtall 3 cleo ga yreall py O15 ediny OM SLES god ager si" y cJelsll jl] 2 Dalal J cleo! 439 O8 cdg Y dads [ay glecall] GLE 2,55 Lene" 1h LS Lt ys Ye pe 3S OMS c0y Bye (AF LLG WEA Sha 3S Late gy Sly be She gua silly glaall- Lie babe lb x 5 Wl joe Ole sll oy glgl BH ge ey jem 10 oy IBS B cle! dled Contradiction astall ne amyl - Relance (GLY! sale!) LSM pe Qerssll - Thématique gle 2 ys) am pl im MES GEL fobasy Jobs oYotoll OF Us 2itall pe Qe - Vberdy gli ly aM ge GE VLy clos 0 Sey Eyl OU >) chile! GIEY oye GastTL Qe I Tbid, p. 152. (1) Ibid, p. 153. (2) Ibid. (3) Tid, pp. 161-162. (4) 116ae Unaad plow a Gaby Gia pny GALY Leb aa gl - sha cle" og pelle lye Me Qe yb eT as ASS 6 AT olay Qe a 85 By O's all DLE] ey eS aly OS phd But OL coos GUI em pay tle pe yall ell = vebne Why dole 6b uals SP oped ghey 5 tere ile ar ye Jaca glially glisy! -3,5 Vala ere de Lebel! 2 pl 5 pleas 6! Ll |LLYI 9 OS WE Rs glint SLAW) (5 suns, dake gulp edt Polit (p35 Lobe Vn Sprard deny Lo glen! CUS IoLy GUoliell GLE] ge Le] GLEYI $203 pe AS GLBYI Aatyall GIEY Ue yd dda go lis) - col" BY ays SI Lene geld 2 yd Lolee bt Lye GEV! JS adh BAU! Joli altee pple (sil USI Oy sll L495 dLel ye (ple ey am GEV y O"Consensus Lp! Le Syd! le sl GUY ge them Ley arbre ple iY yey Balan!) WY ye yo 5 jee TOW Obes aioe ya GEN bs dels teete I lel gs ieee 1 OY seal eed t tele Oj SL ayant Kay ley GUY p ype) ELelid! dell Gls - | OB Sy yo gS lead Mags JR i PASI Jy! of Uzol BB Jacques Moeschler: Argumentation et conversation: Eléments pour une analyse (1) Pragmatique du discours, op. cit, p. 169. Ibid, p. 171. (2) Ibid. (3) 117OO" elit Oj) Sl BLE bee Dy JSS Agel pally GY wbrte" Holy Ud gle ba ty 8 CLAW py gis | eT tre lem olgel pen!" Peels J chs | 4LS3, .Pertinence communicative BU pai Wd (...) Lae as ond Le ates eM Lat Ll JSS ard et Aoually assLg 3, sve} 3 Phatique Seb AV lt] pes hel pl GUY of 2s all oa te i> eda be edi ths ant ye Spt tole WE Je DEY gy GY ge Cd glo let-|@ Igo Sp tell OLAL BY! ge Uo Beye Clby se" JS equ rzbvall Aygo gh Vigghe alard 0" Stal NN ) gan Ua yd ghee gp Mia gba — ell pty be ty Le slidl Gi 5B of Bled le pp Harlem esl pol Ups beads cAnticipée 45Leol Lo sls — \ NW pS.ty Les baal p> pl OF Sey gil alae! Qrodl isla Soll ge Ladd Y lS! OW ye patel pl el GBB gp ga se Uy GUY JL] pany Factuelle Gir Laylbe- Of 5, Syke Sebel 3 LoLT dats ay «fetal! Dol yo null abl ggad Sym foe [glly Gls stot slp! Hel PH JS Soke gil ypally ghey Interactionnelle Llelis La yhie — ¢ op Had Laglela otst 2 TI Gl ZS 3s ani UF Lym coslvall pets a pay Ot ages Jody YS Jalen ag tally Gl oot b> oS Celia Gath YI gid Sab oe ALA slesel Glo ¢ 5 Le ylisll oda dglas - bye Laylin - » Jacques Moeschler: Argumentation et conversation: Eléments pour une analyse (1) pragmatique du discours, op. cit, p. 171. Ibid, p. 172. @) Ibid. 3) Ibid, pp. 172-176. (4) 118GB Saeg Le ee le DEM Gard fosll ge Kai guy ghacall sof dope SNS aS Ue HL pn ene ftce Jo Coe coll TEEN Ag de De 2 pee USS) Mp Gad Hebe aS ge bI I Préventive i565 ib yl oda Lb ys Gyloy Lo slinll ois Gloss Métainteractionnelledlelis - lye Liby - » Pe Anos, boy MO) game Gale ols PF Sse Sbelys Bd” te Gad Say iyglell gd Epes sta Cymer sl ples AMeUS ~ Cell Ho glial) daly JS Teg a oye ctl ds 3 God (98 WIS YS, BEY J! Spell LB AY Ls jliall Ob ule, ABHE] gh Valeoll dhol yd Sy pall Eyhyod) OL Lal FE ee OM Ng ope ol oped Dyess 103] Ls lis Og ON Usd Sel oyme” Jb Ja YIM le gt CLL! ib, Jacques Moeschler: Argumentation et conversation: Eléments pour une analyse (1) pragmatique du discours, op. cit, p. 176. Ibid. (2) 119gl) Gt Lal eel Sled! B (SY! Baty Lobb! 4 Bl OLLI pal cbs ad gil d yl See dy Tb gals Op bry gatas yh eal EUS! Gael Uist gp Letall EbL anal! cle gell sey LL YE LEV ob yey ite tl a> ge a bes ger ry Teele GLE AE ge Lodged LS GLY Jeli oVEw 3 ol Andes Tigdodly Jad! ge ebony cg patil plat ely bast oboal ul spedlenk gS} gal GLE gill detaly sl aly gb cle ely EM phy dually sul ably ¢LI¥) dany (J) ands LUT Uy dade of WS call gash qe eailly Jl, ras oo Halal, Bad by Ge cll Be LSI OLY pe tare eq! byt YW Ga ala 43 plas gill gle Madge ysl” god gow JS dled Lie AS Aylastly Wael cyte gale Glee J aaladl ee KLE gall Lal g toy pte Sy 3) Las Lele Adsl desl pak ple pS ts Lad TAM GSS plinld el yo oye Glass Ley ELI LM! le 22H! Bae hs oy Sled ae eels te Jews vxdldly Jol SMe pated y aol gle pag Le [idee pill 5] 4 3 pall Oba wept epglall chile B SKN pei Hal Gilt ley er Ws Cotmally pid pet trates cS ghas BAS lil Gob gill GLEN! cba Old abel tated! 3! SLI ds gael Jpeg ted CoLl Lie eel By gL MI B94 fal ay sll 120BLS OLAS lly YEW!) BAW Bed Ol glial le ane y lb eM lols Ay BS wg tall I Gas LS. SH, Pl oles! pa oe Wis Jt old clea go Baas Of bLally ASL, Alt ge WS pds LS yal BL Sal ge Sai VY dIBY! es ob Lead QS yl J) Led a Gee Sly 4 So UF his LS Ob ite pale Ly WHy alrod! Laub pe junit Cogeleedl pL filed G31 all [iz beedl 6 gl izle! BI) 5 fee vlad! B clr EWI LL! oe GAS paalis ay ALI, 5G I (ile y Ay all Sa AE) Gye pad eresly Sip etly JIE YL aoe GL] Me Ob pl dite joa Lill Le glis is slinlly Sp le (8 Gli] BV] quls YSU, wales Jardy Sate che Jel ge GULLY ge Ba fe Dt ys by pte Se HAS sls otal J bk OME GVotaald joo HEltSW Lob oT I gel 3} lal debe! A pard eds velba odigh Ls GLE sl ays QAI ole ayylur lg Ae glisdl Lael gi GLY 121Bani cA Mal ca pal Col itt 123Pe gall Stall 3 EBL Ob! 8 Jl OU jet BAU J BBE ad de IMI alll Se J pad Lal pd ply IY Gl BUN 5 GS py Lee Antes ge Lab hoy de tal LEN pb Agile Salles SLT en Lindi La jead hye WLS sho yy 2 ball Dba) Lule Jy! frail at Ay ...0 pb IT Oyler ole Laat Gb peed Ws le SLL ch all gd Lglle pd yo yp peated UI Mia J iW frail Ul deSleall gee pote! ols ts Bln ols Lat le WIS Gshteny BBall yyb5y opts fol ye Unead be ot BBLS! GUI ASS «pls pends Bball we JY Conall PY BASS (AA praadly ible Lee Stl Creal iy Lbs es LI! Lonel iy cyl Ebel JSS J OL bd! pe gs Gata y BIS ESI Olas! ye LAS PIT pley E bE al Ley BLAS EBL gy BLY uke le Ql tI Conall Sy lel Lowell LE eee felis 2 le Cea! poly ge eV ode IST lye EBL Yoleyy SLAB Leldl /AGW lead Ye S35 Way pb, WS cal Slane CST GF Ul ery heey Gatleeal odie ley IME oe Bp be sels Lee J ote OUI Lie 5 SWI fevaill Oo} SIS) aan caaddy grlrodl nll Mis Ly he 552 Us tate salat gly gWly col per ybly at by 125259 2,20) AjBligll pins obo Lyall ealyill ya 127alll 40 soll Asbsligll ayjai 94 PWS aA Btls" tg paedl syle gy! ys BLU aaa Poll Sy feel pally BBEall ge o bis ably Hho gly gil 15 ply Ga) ely Leal BU Leg} bb 1B SY te oof 5 pla OG et IS Abe pd Llane gf UDB BU sSbiy (...) tI foe prey ely Ct tae iy pall Wha ge ty OM as ackee gh OLE LG S bby 23 B gables) oo Gordy Gul pitt og 3) ABU seg oll Oe teres gSull asl iy Ae End ye Ue slpedll he ge eli Ba glaes O59 ly [gine yy Bbball otoy yyhte yl Cie ww of QI} UI ae ON op gS bale] at de ayy cl) Co Ne pb Uy col Seal He AS fo Stal EBS aces 5 OAL Gi! by Le Akl, LS aif C...) 3 bell lat ar gay all Lily” Jb aya Lage SY gp gu Blsall ge dels Sy eae Jy ally oJ J a BL Ob als HELE 05) Le tiny Up OK L deny cle VI gb aie Jory Glyaaly B logde Lee OI bled) aa LL, GT pee, ot] OS gies O38 OT Ep Cemry really dred JE O95 Sy J pally 2 II com ely as gles gb asl sel rey Leis Le pads OS Sy Yor ONS Ry (I dmrasly KSI abe OF SB Labeda Gb Bly Stel ey ayo JS OsALE Gal pres 2219 yo 6 pall! Adare 61994 IU dada cosy es yale slo wo all OLS sy glite gal (1) Stall OLS Dane ay ileoll EbLe 8 seul Galy gyal!” Ul Le gm doe (2) 234 ye 2001 Gayl ou SII 368 6g1993 — 1413 gM deal oy pe Head 2S sla yl cyl Ladies yAle Syl (3) 362 yo 129IU" Logs GyWI OT a yaar ySldeall yer Cee gly ded OLLI Gay Gary clpall sf tied! ge GAS BES Gag agl pes soel BLU Ee lesdl tall OS gpl OH LS OO" asd) de Lill Jaell Al ey dy ill cle Ls) Lyles Lgel yall Laolt ge Lgl ly wlyadly DYE, ee tae Gy pall Lia ge og GS J Lae a LAY, Saal ge fetal Bey plas De WIS cot 3) de gal oT UI Up pee (AI Bal ge tak le 0 Utell pte Gar dp EBay oot Ble GSS pl ces a ole Gado» pty Wadi plod te apley tll pglly part oS Ghee Qoke eljed tof pe Gl Joel Gt Macally Aaale syed Yaar Seles Yates bill ple J ine aw Sears aie oo silly Gall A 46 pd yay ton 1S gga! Sal! ple ML My all ile Belly Jed pe Qabedl GUY JS pod! Ld! oF aly ALS Ge yll gee gilly OLY ge bogs BL aged dead Sl pl ation 5 bball Goldy tbe] ASV Gy pil 3} coed AT Dey By ratty 55 11968 2] 0315 GS tL HL ce NB oe Lf Bele BU BEBE al ple!" dye Coe ety Used oy yal, jl a CMe by Ut sf lar Yl pao sl Bole Bld OS Gi pl Me Cre OM a LUBY octet ge Edy wl pall Ugh] Lake sey ¢ ge oles 3 Gales pt tlie Cod by phy bla og 915 frrlen] 0 pip cl Ma oe der by 35 ye She T hell aly egal!” Ul Le gam dee (1) seislly Aly TLL SHI jo Oyily SN pL 3 Oph ts aE el) AST yo gal zal 691999 - 1419 ey 21 11990 ogg CLI otal ASU Sl CG lial) dane Lm bot cpt" t0alj 6S Ab 3) aed 130Bplay Codd OF phe" 2 ya eGodl sUybly titel BAW erucll ON Sol jad AT dade Ge OB Last gl Le Weel obi al La QJ) sk YL CA LM ll G1 5 all Lael Ws dyed pos Ley 3s deeded Golo Guat ge dad BBE Old Oy poles Otel OF OLN ye ab yy Sul CI Say Bolas! LEI yy bs Gey LONG Blin gas ger yell Heliclly lil! le ppd JVs Las Js" Clete! slay EBLU Eplrodl dill le dln Jae ab Gee welys sod bs ON ABs Go pai iylie de G55 And Gall ger ygSl Ul Le galt lps pte lend! AY ode, dary dre JVI dV! Ble claves Of" rag LS ote gay Gobel) OM Lal py pial" ole ct UL Gey Gad af pee Gal le UYU 05 tI dU fb pure OS Tae Eps sal BY Ge Qt pe JS 2ST Llely gnats cally gredk yes ybuy qratdl ip WES bb ory ALU Oe 29S yale glo Giz pall Lhe gay OMbaly 2 22,5 Woboly OF ead ay rl WN lbs) SE ge JSS EBL oF I Guta dba YS § set sl Chl on WIS: ids" Cal ps U5 Bayle Leashes Bbi I OF I Galbs Lea Gee All Lins! ys ragtlne glee 6 Ball oe 8 OW AY cyeblice gu Jeli! le Lali sae IH ENG BUS) de SE Billy Gah Obst § Dla” 5 £120 Ge 1992 3552 rela 81 Sd PASI ple Apdndy shoul Jpal Re paaall I 2H cy BU DES Te pe gall OV 2,8 +63 2 «2000 sl Jada Gall! heads 2) Pa 63 2 Sha eel gall Gal of Bb cg tall gar (4) 64 0 eens (5) 131lll i toll Ayollaalll ys ,all adldill 94 asboLigll 45-455 ee gol gsi opr Tape grb GUe or i blll Cd che apd WIS B phny Spee dee ge pe GLY Gall BU Ge plas GV Jy Ileal ses all J Jel cals LS ales aL Spel oda Of MGS eally LaMly RLdSI" Olem I ie ab 5 pS > ed LY GE bi Seoby OLY gall GLa pb al By us sheaiy apts cot ESI Jal WDE ge BU ilar smal le Ja pais Hedy Mlbsy Jad Li gbd Sylym Fyeo HLA LS oS tell Ah SY Cds yyltsll fe ete ob gay ole ALY] Ob gall PU O59! wlpedl AISLE Goby A) Lee GUas I daa) oad gall pS Vaal Of dali ul Bae” OF OLem BM pe ab yySall gil et ey Lal of SSI Ene BBall oda Rasny Olas dre op Lyall BU Uy jo gil pS Upeerling Bylyoall GUS 6b ope Ayla] LU! Ge] Lee ars cay pall GU! OMNES ene a Tble Y 5" bil) Ge gall SL al BG Sall JULY Of oi all Gate Lady Rgelpelly GE gle gil LAS PIT, ail ley ert J bs)! LS se MEY dettoes Gol SI dadlae Legs Lal Cals 5] IVR GIS i PLY Ff nad Ob ig pled ay WYy Gilly Cold! cig — elvaed JH ag pl BUI 3S pall SL 2 agi J Geel duns lela b (I) 255-254 50 1994 JVI data Sagat UN 55 pall CLS p yaiiall OES) gill J yall (2) UL aid salem jane ce (2) BB 2 11999 ya — ead Lh 124 yo wnt (3) 132Gilly oles Ye opel sWemly ayy Syl OLA pls wo BAAS STAY Bradt ox gl yay pA phe ot de ad MAI JI US aio y yi 3 bUI be Vp ye Yad de lilly LY CAS By 2", Adal DVL LY lal ne Cleo!" 4 lhl Lah OG BLAS y ENA sae he ahem I Lele plal Nigh Sule! tinall CEL pe ee Bll alley GLY! Lyall Gib LLU! af “ogo gl"y “cathy!” solilas Celt ob cyey Lgmgin; Leyes Lili! aa thie Luts “as ylaally LEYS “Gebel”, "“Yastall, BI, 2, Ll LHe de dpully LW Yd, Lally GSH lg led els OL btslly OL sles tle ge Leh oI firs el oe PASI ple GB shally SPAY OL ble fe ebal gl prs ele sf gliegll 5 ble gh. UjeasSl © PHY OL bury Wl olde yey Wy AAS y by ee PS sey GUS Ebley rl SB Bild o bead ode elyel 5 po CIS LLY yall BA BG act Ob zl BBB OS EBL Of Ole I de ab pS cel WY oltitall Dry CAS Lally UBL do patell Se jLIL EL abal Gyll Geeledtt y ONL faa Le jlory dxperall Baal ed ley o eM gall Gla gb Ebel g cake Gill Gila ees! Of ee grbred GL ge Bae Uns UY ya ad Lt Sd Ugee cla gb oy ply pb devally Gd GUSH ogo al patel gd ol eliall ae Cal Ce od WWW Le poke one atl Bp te 4b SLIGO} JL Bey" Js spl Ollie 5 Ebb! Lie ol si pbs cil! BEY a BEN IS ll gall JU) 5 () yall Jil aw tag plo tle deme (1) 249-220 Gyo 61991 Aygbl can I andl olaed — Oy, tedaly Aly 63 Gyo ty Sde dgAle yl Lede 10 ,AL* yl (2) 66 50 6395 PIS ple Aydndy Nyoll Jpol J Ole Jae cb (3) 221 ye pS PASM ole tudes spol pol J solo Jae ab 4) 133Up od eS gp pull ollie paw J EBL opr y Opler Os tb OE BSL Gy BE Gard! GS Eyre al pills Kod NS VU fe cL ah ele sT le abled igh pat o ESil OVI de or gL Wy doles HOLY Hy pl Lila lbs b sul sal BU oda SL gey BT ge BLL EV Sylelly ae oe eal dad Bb gall te Catt OI ie pall Gael Ble B pee gse Lagll Lally COM 4S etl pS yey slam Gm thy dybll Cy oe Lares Qt jane 85 Le SUS eg padlline Aes 995A gales WI gill Golo pilnany sinll oper ley B bob SV" a Bead gate ofS) aed GIy ope Obs gy pall al LO" pales! pM gall SHI dhol ag No og A SN aye Lae FAIL TLV, 9 oll pls chal te (I) 200 yo 61993 Jy VI dada ela etd Besbeadaall 2001 e929 ~ ebadeh Jl egg all Sal 5S yall Jil eyed egy all ne (2) -107-106-105-9 134alti 2s sol Agolluslll Ay, ll asboligll =dy199 64 alsa ee ell OLA fel EET as ols GI GLI Of BW fi J ols A dyed BLY aed ole Lpler Lae (i rape) Bae BMS sels Nye opel iW ad o sb joel ail Pl id! LLa LS ob lyoul obs coun iy bh be alley Gad yg 3b ageal de Ob Sl yylor or gbail LSy Ugbel os ale y Op bw LG ails SSSI le LLL bo ghil teoe dyad La oe wo shail Hild 4,55 JE Os LIGT Ly glee Of cde yo yall La ode oe REM ley pally Pe pl SLA gd BBE jo As yaxll CY DLS oe ty, BEL" Oe Gy de yk OV) > Opbwl oly of HS HA Cd Lagi Bally ore glee ge duel he at Oana pole oyu Gti Wy Go Be fd bLsI J LS Hels tats CA poled Site ad gay LSM OF LS NS nell 2S") Qrcally Uprl yll Guages Oslo 78" US bes ye cb OY9 dye all Gb potty Cle Yl oljal JS OB Wy aS pl byt ya Wa chased Jibs get! 3 OD ba see 5 be LS C0.) OsbdET Oty glee B lala’ gil Jjtslly ON 5 AU Godan Yorlin: Wme oS i felidl ads JAY elyet _ 45 WY Ol sles Ob UI LS yaad Cll 3B telah py fobs Joan BHEVY lee flr ged Go phy ol pall F5 E BLA CuS by A ye by 9Sde vegas BON gD) 44 ye then (2) 135deere Gls opby atlgber foe Op brat Obs « lol eI}, Lewy, TIE hy Baad OT epee alba CaaS I) Lab" cepa yd soared fuel ply Glas V Slee Vin BAIN 5 ght Oo erg Ble arly) end BBall Gils Uy Rey dy pall Kady pleat Rang: pect Ob IT Sly slus Off HIS yf oles I EU SRL gel Holand he 09 paris ld rues oY La ol A (Gp LI)" Comal Obl Jar HWiy plac! brads ol ey Zl Ab gery te C9 AI OBEY YB poe Ot chee plate Lol OWT 3}. SY gone fab 95 ge parall gh PLT yyy lady gl Le ebled go 9 OU plate] GLI le pusT 5 Late Low Lad he pay sFrancis Jacques Ob~ juni 6 WS SI LS Lian lgles ge bi GES Y ILM pall Ltt 3 5 bill o I APY pl 3 ale A OL besl ge HUIS jLAg Ups obo ede CAS A yell a OMI sm GIN) 0 all gue he gall ily JI BAUM BL SI MAT OLAS 5G OY 55 pe em OL ball eee) SIS tell fo ly Stet de Ge aS Quy ge ULE J ode pb Ligdell ge Col Glee of pty y OU a dob, 9 Sle!” Gs sr peak ily thal claily jyil Sal 3 GEM MLS ag st OL bball en BY Oy il > Rays BUI BEBE Gadel pall Lin cep blzall of U3 Olas Vy Ju" died nal lg jbiSI OL OL BN gy Bll Oyo Biol dy Ley Blind 9p Gly ber Hyg sll ly Geille (1) ely LLU ULI to ogg fall poy Get dere GB y Gat poles! GLIY 6B (2 (1996 al pd) let eglyVI dadall 015 50 68 yo tj 9S de Biol dy Ley Ball Jb Sb ybes ig JUN oly Qt dome (2) 162 Gyo ty 3Sde co dagdll BAW rb, ae as tnt (5) 80 2 andi (6) 136oe Oey ONS clad Lage JS Ugly dla e” .2 yell pyar Lin Gly VY dad os ibley did yo LOW PIG, dglell ut5 able oh SYy Gall Gye Seale BEY gal SL al OL bls Ys ol Lis gu Se AI pe abel OLE os Galball BLY Goll jai bs Cal, COE LI ope Bb le Jae I gg pe ads! CLL ee os ply Pale yy oy chad pla lJ VI Lis Ys Chel SLAG cole AI bes Of dal Cot Le ge EI cle Cables! ge Jelall le ppg GHEY SE Ce LY yl UL di ral 3p ylang ince LS ob ood Gey pall af diy be das ee LD a BL apie ele] I] Ole Ne ab ps pall Sil Leo Agel OG.) Syke Geordy Jaa eng” SLE ys agate Y git alert tes Coed pss U5] BBE feed OMG adler one pls US jay pe OF Shin Sil 5bLs" jetty OLA" fast ce Lad pen OLAS Bp" 2 pee EU ened Y atlas! alg: Ugalane Of pb gba tile teres 55S. WS I gl LES ,abslly Ll dybay SI abd LYLE ae" GU O"spaledl dala!" Ghe UJ 291 AU ae SEAS AUS GI gel LS OSI] Bo) dey GEV Gl 3 EBL lie ls Ud GE de SLEW Gals yp OM rad GLY fares” V gay cdaladt Jy dled ol pall of dies Lb SYbY dybally SLES YB AI Ge Lab Te CASy LLU A paall Ka gpald jalill Le deo Gis kt ad 4) Le gt (2) 200-199 yo 4, glttl «ll «91998 - 01419 Ia bbl yj ne 21-20 Gyo Sde GAS phe dna oul Spel J Oo JI te cb 3) ISS yo andi (4) 24 Geo Sde "Stl, creda ots" «ddl J yall (2) tdi (5) 340 Gyo Se egal Jil 9S (I) gall Jat © 110-9 yo Ske e fiall pypie igs pl aU Le (7) +106 yo ti (8) 105 0 stents (9) 137etedyll tus soll AsboLigll =iLegenge yglai 04 Nobu Sosail adsl 94 See PLY he Tne, ILM gull OL al gd 3 bust Cbs} lye par gel yey Rial ye 2 sill Gaginl Leber bles lyre C1 PU UL val ha 8 Hee ge pS OF AU Aloe Lal CIS 5 FN GS oS phat e tale 0595 Gill day on te BB JJ! te AB eglole cull Olas Gols By BE Ip 3 BU LS izes Merkel ale pay Jed ltl, BEI Tye Eee ye WS Gael by yell By dy Wak Logo BbLally Ulbsd) od doje GS gp Ipod (> gles! ox lpby 5 pail ode JAS 5 bla! bere HU Gil oda ge cil Oe 7083 Gell Ss yl Ble Ling Linkers bya beth ose pasll I ot Ope GU pel dee acl yy thie (5 DLA OLS Lag] B eel So yf Ble LS) BG Jy Nay dey cgealnadt pl SES Beh Bly UBM Lig ool J se Jy MIS gaily Hele te Aye eine Spr dey also! Ble Mb gal oy We oF LS O25 pl ALB Edgell dye pA Bl Gabe gy al te df pF OP Soe! UL hail 1976 in gS Lanladd yy ten COLE dae Gain ol Bl Ope gS! (1) -127-126-125 +158-157 Gyo tends (2) 160-159 yo tends (3) 160 G2 enti (4) 180 2 ents (5) 138

Balaghat Al Iqna3

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Balaghat Al Iqna3

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

You might also like